356 THE JOURNAL OF BOTANY 
L. lweida Ach. Very fine on Craig convene 
L. flexuosa Fries. On palings near Avi 
DL. — Flérke. Glen Eunach, andd on bcageabe ground in 
the for 
L. = idula Fr. On Scots pine in Rothiemurchus Forest. : 
L. sanguinaria L. On old trees in the Larig Ghru, and in 
Glen Eunach. 
L. parasema var. eleochroma Ach. ao in the oe, —Var. 
L. contigua Near Avi 
D. dasvipovnsis Fr. On pire: ane: in the forest near Aviemore. 
L. geographica L. Braeriach, but only seen in small quantity. 
L. petrea Wulf. On stones near Aviemore. 
Verrucaria viridula Schrad. On a stone near Aviemore. 
THE GENUS ROSA IN ‘LONDON CATALOGUE’ ep. 10. 
By W. Barcuay. : 
ig is adie to Reig - few remarks in reply to the criticisms of 
e Revs a. 280) and A. L 328 
(pp. 378.60) (p. 280) ey (p. 328) on my paper 
Mr. Ley says truly that my criticism was directed rather to his 
paper (Journ. Bot. 1907, pp. 200-210) than to the list in the 
_ Catalogue. But how could it be otherwise? The list, so far as 
regards the Villose, could only derstood by reference to his 
paper. a regard to the other principal section, the Hu-canine, 
it would not have been fair enegscaeee - until the completion of 
Major Wolley-Dod's paper on that gro 
R. im r. Marshall ase that in some of the 
Meio of this group the second pee may be £&. Eglanteria 
as or R. tomentella Lem. The hybrid R. spinosissima x R. 
glanteria is not very diffi cult to distinguish, and a sete not be 
para 
: if 
lays much stress seem to be of no account. Borre Hook 
: in Hooker's 
British Flora, ed. 2, p. 231, says: “In both peaaes [i.e. mollis 
; vars. have not un- 
Bak 
p. 212) says vel R. mollis Sm.: “Corolla . . . ictus pland- 
