10 H. BBEAEHCKlfl. 



poeaumio pHTMa, a 3th nooafcAHie BcerAa ropa3Ao caafrfee, q'feM'b H30xpaiiHbie tohbi. Bt> 3tomt> 

 h^ti HHiero eeoSbiqaHHaro a-ih BCBKaro, kto Sjiaate SHaKOMT. ct> MexamiqecKHMt h xninHiecKHMi 

 pa3ApaateHiflMH HepBa. Bt> 9tomt> mojectl y6f>AHTbCH JierKO KaJKflMH, ecjH H3CJi'feAyeT'b ci no- 

 Mombio cTeTOCKona MtitueHHuu tobx, Bbi3BaeBbi0 oahht> pa3T> 3JieKTpHiecKHMT> pa3Apa;KeHieMT> 

 HepBa, a bt> Apyrofi pa3i> MexaHH t iecKHMT>. Hto KacaeTCH xHMHiecKaro pa3ApaaceHifl, to oho 

 flaeTt ^aace Ha Mbirani bt> nojiHOMi. TeTaHycfe Jinrab oiaSbiH niyMi (Bernstein, mob onbiTbi). 

 To ate caaioe BMierb mt,cto no OTHOineHho k-l nojiyqemio BTopnqHaro TeiaHyca ch Mbimn,bi. 

 Oh-b TaK»e nojiyqaeTca 6ojiT>e TpyAHO npn MexaHaqecKOMt pa3ApaJKeHiH, h He yuaeTca (hjth 

 KpanHe piAKo) npn XHMHqecKOMT), TaKiate KaKt npa pa3Apaa;eHiH HHAyKn,ioHHbMH TOKaMH bwco- 

 koh qacTOTbi. Ho sto He Moatert 6biTb nnTBpyeMO (KaK-L to A'fe-naerb r. HHpbeBT, bt> Apyrofi 

 CTaTb-fe), KaKT> apryMeHTt npoTHBT> pnTMnqecKon HaTypbi MbiineqHaro coKpameHia bo Bcfext 

 3Thxt> cjiyqaaxTj h nfeKOTopbix'b aHajiorHqHbixT>. 3totl *aKrb A0JateHT> 6biTb CKopte ofrbac- 

 unewh pacxoHAeHieMt *a3T> B036yacAeHia bt> pa3JiHqHbixT. BOJiOKHaxi,, Kant 9to CA'fc.aaHO Bru- 

 cke, hjih eme pacxoatAeHieM'b phtmobt> bt> pasjiH^Hbixt BO.iOKHax'b, KaKOBbie pnTMbi npn Tpaac- 



*OpMHpOBaHHblXl> B036yatAeHiflXT> OTHIOAb He AOJIHtHbl BO BCtXTb BOJIOKHaXT. OblTb oahhmh H 

 TfeMH 7RQ, KaiCb 3TO C006paffieHie 6bIJI0 BblABHHyTO MHOK) l ). 



CjI'feAyeT'b OTM$THTb, HTO T. HHpbeBT) CaiWb rOBOpHTL Bl> APyrOH CBOeH CTaTbt 2 ), 1TO 



«pa3ApaHceHie HHAyKn,ioHHbiMH TOKaMH Aaerb 3umumeA,bHo SoAbwee OTpiraaTejibHoe Koieoame, 

 HeatejiH TeTaHOMOTopT>» (crp. 44). TaKHMt o6pa30M r t oht> caurb oc.iao'jiHeT'b hjh Aaace yHHTro- 

 ataeTi coBcfcivrb 3Haqeme CBoero «experimentum crucis». Ecjih 6m oht> noJiyqH.n> pe3y.ibTaTL 

 nojioacnTejibHbin (KairB sto 6mjio bt> Monxt onbiTax'b), to sto no3BOJMO 6m CA'fc.aaTb onpe- 

 A^JieHHoe 3aKJiK>qeHie ; ho pe3j'JibTaTT> OTpHnaTejibHbin He Aaen> eniy HHKaKoro npaBa A&JiaTb 

 cboh BbiBOAT), n pa3Bt TOJbKO CA'BJiaTb npeAnojiOHteHie, qTO ero noKa3aTe;ib sjieBTpH^ecKHXi. 

 ocnHJiJifln;iH HepBa 6bWb HeAOCTaxoquo qyECTBHTejieHTb. 



Bott> *aKTbi, Ha KOTopbix'b noKOHTCfl 3aKJnoieHie r. HnpbeBa, tto bt> mohxi onbiTaxt 

 TeJie4>0HHqecKiH toht. 6bWh «BBJieHie ihcto <fiu3mecKoe, a He (fimio/ionmecKoe». 



BcBKin Apyrofi 3KcnepHMeHTaTopi>, nojiy^HBi OTpna,aTejibHbie pe3y.ibTaTbi, cjejn> 6bi 

 CBOHM"b AOJiroM-b npoKOHTpoJiBpoBaTb npeatAe Bcero qyBCTBHTejibHOCTb CBoero noKa3aTejifl *h- 

 3HqecKaro, a hotomt> CBoero aHajiH3aTopa #H3iojiorHqecKaro, TaKi> KaKi a^Jio HAeTT> o SBynaxi 



CpaBHHTeJIbHO CJia6blXT., XOTfl H BOCnpHHHMaeMbIXT) BCBKHMI yXOMT) HOpMaJIbHOH OCTpOTbl. 3Toro 



mh He yciwaTpHBaeM'b H3T. CTaTbH pa36npaeMaro aBTopa. 



Bt> OBHcaHin cbohxt> ouhtobx oht> Haiwi. He AaeTL HBnaKoro acHaro npeACTaBJieHia o 



1) Archives de physiologie 1891, JV»J\» 1 h 2. 



2) HapteDT.. H3BicTifl HMnepaTopcKoH AuaAeMiH HayK^, 1902, TOMt XVII, N° 1. 



