CHAPTER VIII. 
THE CAUSE OF THE DECLINE. 
JOINT AGREEMENT OF 1892. 
At the joint meeting of American and British investigators in 1892, preceding 
the Paris Arbitration, an agreement was reached that “since the Alaska purchase a 
marked diminution in the number of seals” on the Pribilof Islands had taken place, 
and that this diminution was “the result of excessive killing by man.” But when an 
attempt was made to analyze what was meant by “excessive killing” each commission 
took a different view. The commission for the United States claimed that it was the 
slaughter at sea of female seals that was responsible; the commissioners for Great 
Britain held that land killing was chiefly, if not wholly, responsible. 
As has already been shown, the decline admitted in 1892 has continued to the 
present time and is still going on. It only remains for us now to locate if possible 
the cause of the decline, to distinguish between land and pelagic killing. 
NO NATURAL CAUSE COMPETENT TO EXPLAIN THE DECLINE. 
{t may be remarked at the outset that the investigations of the past two seasons 
have brought to light no natural cause of injury to the herd which can be connected 
with its decline. The subject of mortality among the fur seals is discussed in detail 
in Part III of this report. It is only necessary here to say that among the adult seals 
no mortality was found which was not due, directly or indirectly, to contests among 
the bulls, or to rough treatment of the cows by the bulls. In the case of the very 
young pups an hitherto unknown but apparently customary cause of death, due to the 
ravages of a parasitic worm infesting crowded and sandy breeding areas, was found 
to be responsible for a large number of deaths. In the case of very young pups a 
certain number are also trampled to death by the bulls. The number dead from these 
causes in 1896 as counted amounted to 11,000. Doubtless a considerable number were 
overlooked. 
NATURAL CAUSES OF MORTALITY CONSTANT. 
_ It may be said, however, that both these causes of death are as old as the herd 
itself, aud were more active when the herd was in its prime. They are directly related 
to the crowded condition of the rookeries and are, therefore, to-day, at a minimum. 
The photographs! taken by the British commissioners in 1891 and 1892 show that the 
'A photograph taken in 1891 by Dr. George M. Dawson shows a part of the sandy northern end 
of Tolstoi rookery thickly strewn with dead pups, evidently killed by the worm. The photograph 
will be found among -the illustrations in Appendix II. In the following year Mr, Macoun reports 
finding by actual count 4,000 dead pups on the sand flat of this rookery. These facts, tending to 
show the presence of breeding seals and their young in territory far beyond the present confines of 
Tolstoi rookery, are also valuable as proving the great shrinkage of this rookery since 1891. 
115 
