ANCIENT AND MODERN STANDARDS. 



159 



The extreme of neither argument will bear examination. 

 On the one hand, it is impossible to admit that we ai-e to be 

 tied down to every point precisely as known to Moore ; and 

 it is simply an egregious mistake to argue, as some have done, 

 that the points as described by old authors were always the 



Blue ahd 'White Jacobihs, 



result of careful study, and deliberate, fixed determination. 

 This position has been assumed by more than one advocate of 

 the old-fashioned Jacobin; but it is, on the contrary, as certain 

 as anything can be that many of the varieties were far from 

 settled in Moore's time, and that a general consensus of opinion 

 had hardly begun to exist. The Carrier has been not only 

 lengthened in face, but far improved in other properties, since 

 Moore's time ; and who would go back to his standard, or even 

 that of "Mayor," for the Almond Tumbler] As regards the 



