04 Animal Intelligence 
TABLE 6 (c) 
Doc 3 Inrratinc Doc 1 
Times Times Times Time 3 was 
1 did 3saw Doubtful in alone 
30 10 10 10.00 F 
After x Hour 30 9 10 10.00 F 
After 1 Hour 15 6 4 
After 24 Hours 30 9 II 15.00 F 
After 24 Hours 30 Io 12 15.00 F 
After xz Hour 30 8 9 10.00 F 
After 48 Hours 20 6 7 40.00 F 
After 1 Hour 20 6 5 
After 48 Hours 30 8 9 15.00 F 
After 24 Hours 15 3 4 20.00 F 
Total times surely and possibly seen, - 75 81 
Another corroborative, though not very valuable, experi- 
ment was the following: Dog 3 had been taught for the pur- 
“pose of another experiment to jump up on a box and beg 
when I held a piece of meat above the box. I then caused 
him to do this 110 times (within two days) in the presence of 
1. Although 1 saw him at least 20 per cent of the times (3 
was always fed each time he jumped on the box), he never 
tried to imitate him. 
_'It seems sure from these experiments that the animals 
were unable to form an association leading to an act from 
having seen the other animal, or animals, perform the act in 
a certain situation.' Thus we have further restricted the 
association process. Not only do animals not have asso-| 
‘ciations accompanied, more or less permeated and altered, 
by inference and judgment ;- they do not have association: 
of the sort which may be acquired from other animals b 
imitation. i What this implies concerning the actual mental! 
