85. SAXIFRAGACES, 517 
having seen it in both counties in out-of-the-way nooks, which, if 
not always inaccessible, could offer no temptation to any one to 
take the trouble to plant it there.” 
Cotyledon lutea, Huds. 
Provinces 1 10. Somerset; (Clement) Huds. York; Tofield. 
Error. Cyb.i. 404. The plant of it in Chelsea Garden, given by 
Hudson, was more likely brought from Mr. Clement’s garden, not 
from Yorkshire. 
35. SAXIFRAGACER. 
Sawifraga Cotyledon, Linn. 
Province - 12. Westmoreland; Phytol. ii. 429. 
Error. Cyb. i. 405. Perhaps more truly an imposition. 
Saxifraga umbrosa, Linn. 
Provinces 1---5--891011 121314 15. 
Alien? Cyb.i. 406. Planted in many places. Mr. Tatham 
deemed it native in Heseltine Gill, West Yorkshire. And Mr. 
Brand is quoted in Cyb. Brit. as follows: ‘“ On Craig-y-barns, a hill 
to the northward of the Park at Dunkeld, covering acres, and, in 
some places, to the exclusion of everything else, forming the entire 
turf. But for the occurrence also of Hypericum calycinum, and 
other introduced plants, it would have been considered native.” 
But against this fairly-given testimony of Mr. Brand there is 
something more positive than the suggestive counter-evidence of 
Hypericum calycinum and its associates. In the ‘ Correspondence 
of Sir J. E. Smith’ i. 516-7, we find a letter from Mr. Winch, 
expressly stating that the Saxifrage was introduced into the woods 
at Blair Athol, by the gardener. Whether his introductions 
extended as far as Craig-y-barns does not (from memory) appear in 
the letter. 
Saxifraga Geum, Linn. 
Provinces - 10 11 [12] 18 14 15 16. “Only where planted.” 
Alien. Cyb.i. 405. [12 Westmoreland. Cumberland.] 
Saxifraga rotundifolia, Linn. 
Province - 12. Cumberland; Phytologist, ii. 376. 
Error. Cyb. i. 404. Recorded on hearsay report only. 
Saxifraga Sibthorpii, Boiss. & Sprun. 
Province - 16. Near the Crinan Canal, Argyle; Mr. W. Bennett. 
Casual. Eng. bot. iv. 87. “8. Cymbalaria.” 
Saxifraga muscoides, Wulf. 
Province - 12--? Westmoreland; Huds. ‘“ Highlands”; E.B. 3. 
Error. Cyb. i. 416. Eng. flo. ii. 272. Eng. bot. iv. 87. 
