1 85 1 .] Comparative list of Upanishads. 6 1 9 



8 of the Atharva Veda Upanishads in common with Mr. Elliot's list 

 (viz. 1, Munda. 2, Pras'na. 3, Atharvas'iras. 4, Atharvas'ikha, 5, 

 Mandukya. 6, Atma. 7, Nrisinha-Tapaniya. 8, Brihad-Narayana.) 



6. Thirteen Upanishads are counted in Anque til's collection to the 

 Atharva, which are assigned in Mr. Elliot's list to other Vedas. (viz. 

 1, Kshurika. 2, Garbha. 3, Maha. 4, Prana, (Pranagnihotra.) 5, 

 Amrita-Bindu. 6, Tejo-Bindu. 7, Dhyana-Bindu. 8, Yogasikha. 

 9, Yogatattwa. 10, Aruniya. 11, Kathaka. 12, Kena. 13, Nara- 

 yana. 14, Paramahansa. 15, Kaivalya. 1G, Jabala. 17, Amrita- 

 Nada. 



7. The following are exclusively found in Anquetil's list. 



1, Hansanada. 2, Atmabodha. 3, Shekl or Pankl, (Sakalya W.) 

 4, Amrita-Lankoul, (Amrita-Alaukara W.) 5, Taraka (perhaps Ta- 

 rasara.) 7, Arkhi (Akshi?) 8, Saunaka (Savank.) 9, Padeva. 10, 

 Sattarudriya. 11, Sivasankalpa. 12, Purushasukta. 13, Vashkala. 

 14, Tshakli. 



8. From the above comparison it is evident, that the three lists have 

 been taken from different authorities, and it is probable, that yet more 

 will be found, of different numbers and arrangement. Which of the 

 treatises, called Upanishads, are taken from the Vedas themselves, 

 and which are added to them at a later period, cannot be decided, be- 

 fore all the Vedas are published, when it will be possible, gradually to 

 ascertain the time of their composition. 



9. The whole number of Upanishads according to the three lists 



and other authorities is : 



and added the parts which in 



other arrangements are consi- 

 dered as different Upanishads. 



Of the Telingana list, 108 120 



Added by Mr. Elliot, 3 3 



Of the Atharva Collection, 7 7 



Of Anquetil's list, 14 14 



Of other sources, 6 10 



138 154 



4 k 2 



