May 30, 1880.] 



FOREST AND STREAM. 



m 



entry. Byron (Bob-Frinml) was a Very showy dog, in 

 good condition, fljae Color, and wol 1 proportioned . 



"jo, however, , i | jlcho III. (Isteho- 



Ruse'i, who was a superb animal and a thoroughly typical 



is class. We make no comment on the remain- 



inc.- awards, believing- them to be. most justly distributed. 



Twenty-seven entries covered the bitch class. Drayton's 



Borah (Berldy-Till 



was by far - 



quality, and Newbol 

 fair specimen. Bass 

 New' York in 1877, ai 

 same place, received 

 Hopkins Smith Jack 

 look of being oliler ll 

 (Berkly-Duck) second, a 

 flitch puppies, twemy-sb 

 toade outside the winne 



Id 1 



Hit of the 



3 the pro) 



■autiful bitch, won first. She 

 lor entry In her class. Shrere's 

 ne next with second, splendid in 

 a Viscountess third, the latter a 



rd'a Gipsey, first in puppy class at 

 third in bitch class last year at 

 o mention. In the dog puppies, 

 Elcho-Meg) first, with a suspicious 



:lve months, Wonzel's Chief 

 ,' promising-youngster. In (lie 

 auniber. there was no mention 

 ave of I Infills Belle Elcho. 

 sedvted a very high mention. Wo think 

 lave been one or two other youngsters 

 To sum the awards up. it Will be seen 

 prizes covered nuder this heading, six 

 Of the famous Elcho, three firsts be- 

 Fuvther remark is u 



;lei 



— Thi 



lalurd's 



1 th 

 ,ud one of Skidmore's I. 

 i wiggy top-knot. Sec 

 nown" winner Mike. Ov 



s not in bench show- 

 not of his breed. Mike 

 I one of the best retri 

 awler's Judy, tram Sh 



lditi. 



it h« 



est breedini 

 :ond was e 

 vnetl by \V 

 lOIitlitiou, 

 is thoroui 

 >f 



is a fair class, with 

 ish imported Barney 

 , but rather laded ih 

 deal dog of his class, 

 , though with rather 

 warded to the well- 

 Mis, of Canada. He 

 md lacked the top- 

 lily a working dog, 

 Id fowl in America. 



— Maxwell Shaw Stewart's Ken- 

 nels, Glasgow, was un fortunately overlooked. She was 

 a rare good one, 



Cv.UiniEHS.— Tileston's Trimbnsh and Fairy, the noted 



f last ye 

 lv. The 

 id, and 1 



■'ssliow, received the drat and second de- 

 breed of clumbers is running down in 

 it few of the short headed ones are to be 

 ,; llftfl given up their breeding, for 

 . prominent fifteen years ago. 

 ir.i.D Spaniels.— The dog class, contain- 

 judged to our idea, 



warded to Willev' 

 el type. A cock 

 :tween the eves, 



: head 



ntic 



id ears, - 

 Itches were placed > 

 - Sussex breed, was 



Bach's Queen Tic, 

 and tors, eillelan'i 

 vganfs Ely, unnotk 

 ig of third' place. 1 

 d dog, but too large, 

 n ordi nary lot. 

 raomros.— The class 

 ii shape, style and si 



il of 



mst have no top- 

 eating the water 

 a showy liver and 

 :• pounds weight. 

 1 white, received 

 iijou. a Sussex, was unnoticed, 

 lisnwiok's Puck 

 s of the Norfolk 

 iplendid fellow. 

 01 t ne Welsh strain, had an ex- 

 hich were, however, too curly. 

 iiuch better. Macdougal's Cora, 

 ; very good and deserved first, 

 a Norfolk, second, with good 

 S Bady, third, we did not like, 

 ;ed, a real fine animal, was tle- 

 the puppies, Wvganl's Music. 

 eoeived first. The others were 



■folk liver an 

 a Susses 

 if the lot. 

 H. C. He - 

 nd a 



the third too light ai 

 Puvogel's Tyler, win 

 solid Knglisii hound. 



ih. IA.GU5S.— A really 

 he seen, as they all 

 Toledo Kennel Club, ^ 

 the others placed hi 

 ■ferever, should have 



WASChunde. — In tl 



a poor one, the dogs being 

 Seiner's Trim, a dog with a 



it. The second was only fair, and 



leggj No mention was made of 



Was the best in the class. A good 



- poor class, and not a typical one to 

 leaned toward the harrier breed, 

 with Keckless, fairly came first, and 

 . proper order. Penfold's Charley. 

 ibeenmenti 



lot there were some excellently 

 colored dogs, particularly the black and tans. The class 

 was well judged; Scheelje's red dog Dan, a vervfinospeci- 



rvedly received , first, his only fault being one 



common to his species, that is, pigged jawed. Claussen's 

 Mollke. a good black, second. This breed is now huh ,,£ 

 the most fashionable in England. 

 Box Tekkiuks. — A fair class, with some excellent coats 

 id ears. Mortimer's Shot first, a dog with a short, 

 ick face between good ears, excellent in body and sub- 

 tee. In the bitches, Rutherfurd's Active, a' white and 

 :k, came first, and same owner's Chance second. 

 filer's Judy third, although she showed more quality 

 n either of the other winners. Burke's Nettle, and 

 f's Tort were both good specimens and deserved high 

 ntion. The puppies, dogs and bitches, counted up to 



-enty -nine i u all. TUeston's Vampire, first an ' 



'urine r, and Fleck's Gipp, a real good bitch, in the. latter. 

 irneU's Prima. Donna, unnoticed, was too good a puppy 

 to have had a mention. 



:ys. — This class was an excellent show, and in- 



a great many excellent animals. The first and 



id, namely, Lindsay's dog Rex and Downey's Las- 



ts, who alsi 

 fflfi-show, w 



Jrhaps the 



, las 



i the 1 



Me 

 I all pi 



tlal 



i (be 



.eh 



utiont 

 in An 



:olIey bitch 

 6od's Jock third, 

 nlass, but head in- 

 .-ing a less reliable 

 ^cording to John 

 . — she Won first at 

 a fair lot, Apgars 



The puppii 

 first, a splendid eolley all over. Greeley's Guggle 

 was thrown out on account of " Puck " ears, otuer- 

 t very good youngster. 



X Docs.— Sir William Verner's dog Donald first, 

 irnard's Judy second, both of the fashionable type 

 ijr breed in England at the present day. Miller's 

 --), first of last year, received no mention. 



krikks. — Sir William Verner again won in a 

 toter in this class with champion Tarquin and his son 



The presence of these dogs, and the 

 Vido reputation of the former as a winner, added a 



io attraction of the show. Tarquin, the, I pineal 

 lis elass, was bred by Mi'. Vero Shaw, and sold 



"' ovei 'H j bis present owner. Asa collector of 



baa no equal, having landed one hum [red md 



•vo prizes and fourteen special cups. ife still showed 



.. of his undutifnl son's conduct, and vvaB evi- 



iible humor. Mr. Wills' Victor 



ftoeived third, and there were sever)*] otk good '' 



ivorld- 



in the class, though Mr. Dalziel expressed his opinion 

 that the Yankee breeders were too Ediidof stacking to 

 "thefightinghi 



5BIBBS, — One of the best classes in the show, 

 almost all the entries appearing in splendid ooater, fijhn 

 Bonis Harberger's Patch and Tatters won the first and 

 second, as they most probably would do at any of the 

 shows in England. Walton's Pepper— a good one— third, 

 and Aspinwall's Puppy and Vugt's Jeff close upon his 

 heels. 



Ptius,— The English judges pronounced this to be a 

 fair class, and we presume that they alluded to many of 

 the exhibitors, who carried the ugiy little brutes in their 

 anus. It never occured to us until recently wdiy these 

 I ■■■.-headed dogs had wormed themselves into so 



.d'Beai 



belie 



id IlieB... 



ids on Thursday last, v 

 st pleading looks, and 

 ■ir pens without a in 

 re few, but rightly g 

 ■k first. MissDetcho' 



id the dai 





ce. The ; 



w .rds 



■ii, Dagg 



stt'S fa 



ported Ro 



leriek s 



for th 

 ,st ( 





i Prince, a golden fawn, third. First, second 

 and third were correcOy placed, and Miss King's Peggy 



certainly deserved all shegot, 



BrxdCH TERKIEHS, — An exceedingly poor class, in 

 which the money liad to be withheld. " Hazard's Pepper 

 came in for second. 



Black and Tan Terriers.— Sir William Verner's Sal- 

 ford, a superb rascal, had an easy win of lirst, with 

 Nettle, belonging to Mr. James Watson, London, Eng- 

 land, second, and the rest of the entries trotting at a re- 

 spectable distance behind, 



Dandle Dinmonts. — This breed of dogs, made so famous 

 by Sir Walter Scott, had but two really first elass entries, 

 first going to Pin and second to Needle, both being recent 

 importations of Mr. Hume, of Virginia, 



Yorkshire Terriers. — This was a really good elass, 

 including both large and small dogs. Kallaher's Willie 

 first, Roger third and Collins' Royal second, in the over 

 five pounds class, and the former owner the first two 

 prizes in the small class. 



Tot Terriers. — A class with eighteen entries, two- 

 thirds of which received mention. Miss Clancey's Bijou, 

 a remarkably fine specimen of the apple-headed black 

 and tan, received first. This was the smallest dog in the 

 show-, weighing but one and three-quarter pounds, 



Japanese Spaniels.— Also a grand elass, which we 

 examined with great care. We differ, however, with the 

 judging, believing Allison's Chang was more properly 



Ititled to first than same owner's Ching. 



Italian Greyhounds.— Another splendid class, with 



ght out of the ten entries mentioned. Mrs. Foster's vory 

 beautiful Princess scored first, with the other winners 

 close behind. 



Silk-Haired Terrieks. — Three good entries with Clif- 

 ford's Jess, a silver gray, a.s first, and Miss Wugstalt's 

 Scamp, a blue backed, second. 



Micellaneous.— A mixed up lot, 

 Bion, called in the official catalogu 

 hound, but which to us looked like an ETlm badly bred. 

 Second to Troy's Rajah, a very good 

 o Watson's Kathleen, an Irish ton 

 f the few we have seen in this c 

 Genzel's Jocko and BoriUard's Camel 

 was no notice made of Godelfroy's C 

 although he was a good one, or of Kyle's Rover, Ni 

 foundland and St. Bernard. Kinn's pair of Caniches, 

 Bella and Carlo, received very high mention, but were 

 tintrimmed. 



Tappan's Sancho was a very good-looking dog, by One- 

 eyed Saucho out of Flora, and it was the opinion of 

 others than ourself that he was of finer type than several 

 of the winners— he was passed unnoticed. Godeffrov's 

 Satan, a verv well-made black dog. was awarded a V, H. 

 C— well deserved. Schielfelin's Pericles (Sensation- 

 Juno) received a high comiuendalion, and wo think a 

 higher place should have been given Inm. Aldrich's 

 (setter bitch) Smut, also winner of the club medal special 

 prize for best black setter bitch. 



"Nl'/K" ON the Show. — Such a number of pointer.-, 



and setters has nevei before been 



there was little, if anr" n Ijish" i'ug Ihern. Thesahae 

 ea.nnol, m a l] Is. * - all the clasws. The 



mastifi's need improvement, and with wider jaws and 



less pointed mu/.zles would make a bettel shuwin,. i-uiu- 



iug- nearer to the type, and ill tti 



The St. Bernards were better, but still capable of im- 

 provement. The Newfoundlands came up to the expec- 

 tations of the critical judge, and surpassed it : they be- 

 ing first class in form and with good coats as welt. " The 

 puppy class here promises e< J hounds:, as 3 



class, were good, with a good leader and fair followers. 

 Here, as in other sections of the show, Better results 

 would follow more attention to condition. Several eases 



happening where really g I animals lost the" ribbon he- 



cause they were out of condition, when thev might as 

 Well have been in prime . -bowing stage. The (ieerhounda 

 were a. fine elass. and then came Ihe pointer and setter 

 class, of -which something has been already said. The 

 bitches ni the former were exceptionally line in all the 

 numbers. The Dasdhunde found good leaders for the 

 first prize taker being especially good. The 

 coneys, too. are worthy of great commendation, and at 

 coming collev trial, if "the results arc up to the bench 

 level, the class will be up to Scotch standards. The 

 Scotch terriers Were down again, and pure blood was 

 looked for in vain, In the many arbitrary points among 

 ih - Skj es -' inn were found to nieet all, aiid as a lot they 

 were really admirable, and set lovers of t heir breed beside 

 themselves in piling up the adjectives. 



BDLL LIST Ot? THE AWARDS. 

 [V.Il.l'., very liig-hty commended ; H. C, highly comui«ndcd : 



us? t— Mastiffs DpgS.- Mnrf prize, 520, Churl Ml'. Hull's Turk, 



■-Yurie: seen, id, sis. \U.,ei-l lluvsnelCs lv a nvi t ., dale Duke!, 



l.-..m,N, V ; V.ll. v.. Dr. AII'.Tt 11. lim-k':, Harm, Now York - 



."'s Ih-i-eward, New lurk. II. C, Oliver K. Hand's 



ass'a— MnstltYs-Uitches.-First prizr, S20, Albert Hovsradt'B 

 ., Hudson, x. v.: aei d, 810, J. M. Dnaerwood's (Jueea, New- 



W.J. i Ihit-l, silver uiedal, t(. Lehmaun's Juno, Brooklyn, 



. aasB-Jtfastia Puppies— Dors nml Bili-lus.-Kirat prize, ?10, S. 



C. Hewitt's UriMiilu, New York : aecoud, silver nipdul, Ii. L. Ilellc- 



p's Venus, New York. V. H. (J„ C. D. Arthur's PlutO, Ncov 



JHi=s t- HOttgb Coined St. Burnaril Doss. -lorn prize, 830. A. R 

 ideirrny's .Marco, < nuiw Co., -N. v.: second. Sltl, D. P. Poster's 

 imi, N r ew York; third, silver medal. Ii. Li-lmmnu's Kulf, 



th fl 



rstto Deln 



a 



Danish lx 



Bin 



i badly bre 



ar li 



aund. Thi 



, on 



3 of the bt 



nl.rv 



Fourth 



selu 



ratrtz, The 



tic.be 



Pagolbc:.! 



During the show the 



Committee, of 



the Westminster 



Kennel Club had a nuiul 



jer of protests 



landed into them; 



we have, however, notic 



ed the only o 



ic that was enter- 



tinned. In making our t 



riticisni3 of th 



? different classes, 



we were glad to avail ou 



rselves of the i 



pportunitv which 



offered to refer some of tl 





uable points to our 



friend, Dr. A. Russell St 



•achan, weU ki 



town as one of the 



pioneer judges in this country, whose, opinions were sus- 

 tained by many other competent critics present, 



Mr. Godeffroy's Protests.— May 12th.— The. West- 

 minster Kennel Clnb, New York.— Gentlem.en : I beg to 

 protest against the award in class 5, where my bitch 

 Braunfels'was given the second prize. The other dog has 

 no dew (daws, a point which is, according to Stonehenge 

 and Vero Shaw, as necessary as solid white in a bull ter- 

 rier, Yours respectfully, A. E. Ctodefproy. 



Mail mi).— The Westminster Kennel Club. New York — 

 Gentlemen; I protest agsmst the award in class ifl, clmm- 

 piun<4onioii setter bitcheft Ihe dog awarded has a funda- 

 mental fault, viz., fawn colored nose and blacli mark- 

 ings on the feet. Please examine Stonehenge, and 

 oblige. Yours respectfully, A. B. ' ■■;■ \i i ■■-.. 



May %%t%.— To the Manar/ers Westminster Kennel Club 

 Dug Shuiv, New 1 or};.— Gentlemen : While knowing that, 

 under Ride 10 of the Fourth Annual Bench Show of the 

 Westminster Kennel Club, I am without redress against 

 any award rendered by the three judges of the present 

 ■theless I deem it due to the reputation of my 

 kennels to formally protest against the decision renderei 

 by Messrs. Wise. Hammond end Dak.iel, in then- judg- 

 ment of class 10, for pointers over lifty-live pounds, in 

 which my my dog Cro.vteth was only awarded an tl. C, 

 while other dogs, infinitely inferior to hbniat least ac- 

 cording to Stonehijuge), were given higher awards. 



I deeply regret being obliged to enter a protest, as at 

 (be many previous shows where I have exhibited I have 

 never bad occasion to do so before, and my qbjeel m ' 

 ease is to make my protest a matter of reco'r 



future, ami enable brother sportsmen to see ths dog i 

 and judge for themselves, J am, gentlemen, youi's ce 

 spectfully, A, B ' d 



..lied St, lieriiiin! Cin-hns.- l-'h-sl gtize, S30, H. 

 ■ l:i. Nlov York; second, S1U, A. K. (indellruy's 



I prize. S30, 

 u WciVhell's 

 alnos' Tilly, 



..4688— St. Bernard Puppies-Dogs an 



SHI, .lolui P. Humes' Anion. Tiiiin P.iv, 

 medal, .lolui P. Haines' Tiff, Tom's 1' 

 Hftluos" Bex, I'lini':, IHver. H. C. John 



'iou-m- A. Poor's Churl. -y. Brooklyn. V. 1I.IJ., Louis A Icx.-indfii-g 



'■ ,'■■"''. ■-.:...:.■. .-.■: ..-.-,:.-. id, Jr.'s J'lccl. \..ov Y..rk, l.'ni.. ■■-. 



Fitzroy's Bruno. Greenwich, Coiui.; Albert Meiert Turk.Pater- 

 soii, N. J. n.C, M.Tueiiliruiil's. lira Fisk, New York. C, J. O. 

 i '! n.i - N" cm, Crawford, N. J.; Dr. Thomas C. .Slellwiwen's 

 Xcidiine, Pluliidelphia. 



Class lO-Acwfoiuidlaud Punpic- Doirs and Bitches.— Prize, 

 silver medal, D. A. BioKham' is I -..« York. Y.H.O.,Dr. 

 Timmiis '..sviiv ;. ■■. ■•- '. ..;,. iclplihi; II. C, John Duff's 



i-ns'li". tfot in'., i :.,i Lit roln Cee Beris :fe«r York, 



nml W.TJetjei -i. -v.... .:.-.i'. i»tra Vauey.N. Y. 



Class ii -s,c ,.,.;;,, ,, „ r xnm Dogs or Bitolies.— First prize, S15, 

 Adolphc \on Scliades Sulnni, iVi-vrnort, K. I.: second prize 

 mIii i- in '.Id, 1 1 In ICcIlcr's I, von, New' Ynrk; ihird (cxlni), Mrs 

 .1. M. Uuiau-s Hex. lirnoldvn. Y.H.C., Onorj.-c- Pmciinann'S 



i James J < '■ ■ 1 1 . y'a Major, tin- 

 Flora, .s.'V.- 'i'crk. ami Thomas 



nl"liitches.-lorsti prize, Jl.i, J. 



. .. d, silver medal, H. A. (bolt's Ho- 



rnon.N. Y. V IT. C. G.TYalton's Thorousrhl cod, 



nd .1. f'hairy's Pitta. New York. H C. e'lillord 

 ■ Viscnuut, I'J'-nv Ilri-luou, S. I , and r. s. Mvcr's 

 i . C, Hall, Blair & Co.'s Guess and Gem, Broofc- 



tlOUnds— Dogs and Pilches -First prize. MS, Paul 



i i- - ■ aid. silver medal, P, T. Barlnw'f, 



■k. \ Hi'., we. Ilcv.-iirs Sorl'i-aia, New York, 



- Mpidart, Newport, It. 1.; Paul Dana's 



it..r- ever 55 Pounds-Dogs.— Prize, $35, 

 i-.s-licx. Uiiioklyn. NY 



nt.-is .oer jil Pounds— Bitches.— Prize, 



fork; n , Jbl 



n M.- 



rshali's 11. 



Sehndc'sTie'ei 



If. 1. 



H. C. .1 





.iilla. 



, New Vo 



lioken.Js. .1. I 





ir-e Ctricl 



1 .-,, II,'- Po 



Chee 



c. Paierso 



Class 13— Gre 



•stuier's Print'. 



v ;;/;,' 



s- -Dogs 



ds— Dogs.— I 



;-.e, ?30. E. 



1, .III I se,,,! .1, .-.-II, 



lilver medal, J. w. 



. . I '. .■■.-!. [■ 



. A K. c: ■- ■ , I e I ,,,., 

 Laurence's Sank, 



.IT— Pointers ov 



liters over ;,0 Pounds -Birches.- First prize, $30, A. 

 ella, Philadelphia; second, S;ID, David U. Harft's 



■ amVion Pointers under 55 Pounds— Dogs.— Prize, 



) Pounds— Bitches.— Prize. 



New York. 



□ .■.-■ I Irs -e. . 130, H 



n-li; third, sfln 

 u-k. V.H.C., 

 .urn 1/s Bit. Nei 



", $;w, 

 a. \y. 



-. Cor- 



H. C, 



AY est - 



. n d Edmund Orgill's Rue, Brooklyn. H. C, J. W. 



,.,'-, i....a, Providence, » I.; Garrett Roach's Marvel New 



. A... I.'., Mrs. Clias. M. Schictlel ii.'s puiipv, iSciinu .n ', . 

 Wesici.esicrCouuly, N. Y. 



Cliiso.'-t-i'lminpioii Ene-lishl Sellers lie' . 'ne lis, I ir.S. Fleet 

 Speh-e. St. Fame. Brooklyn. 



'I lUEiiJilisli Sellers- :i. ,, ..-Prize, S33, Arnold 



fll I e.-'.n . 1 'In Io .l.'.l I-' ','!,. . 



(Contvnmd on Page 817] 



rizo, $30, 

 ,-, , 

 .. 11. Moore's fluke 

 licld'B ftoynl Carle, 



