Annals of Horticulture 



III. The Downing Lists, 1845 and 1872. 



The first edition of A. J. Downing's "Fruits and. Fruit- 

 Trees of America " appeared in 1845; the second revision, 

 much augmented by Charles Downing, appeared in 1872. The 

 entire list of apples of the revision is reproduced in the in- 

 ventory below, and the entries which also occurred in the 



