VOLUME 3 DECEMBER, 1917 NUMBER 12 
PROCEEDINGS 
OF THE 
National Academy 
OF Sciences 
OF THE 
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 
EDITORIAL BOARD 
Raymond Pearl, Chairman 
Arthur L. Day, Home Secretary 
Edwin B. Wilson, Managing Editor 
George E. Hale, Foreign Secretary 
J. J. Abel 
J. M. Clarke 
E. G. Conklin 
C. B. Davenport 
H. H. Donaldson 
E. B. Frost 
R. A. Harper 
W. H. Holmes 
J. P. Iddings 
Graham Lusk 
A. G. Mayer 
R. A. Millikan 
E. H. Moore 
A. A. NoYEs 
Alexander Smith 
Publication Office: Williams & Wilkins Company, Baltimore 
Editorial Office: Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge 
Home Office of the Academy: Washington, D. C. 
Entered as second-class mattet at the Post Office at Baltimore, Md., under the Act of August 24, 1912 
