OOi Kidd V. Royal Agricultural Society of Enyland. 
Mr. Seymouk : Will you ask him, my Lord, whether it alters his opinion 
of the cake 
Mr. Justice Blackburn : I do not think that bears upon the issue at all ; 
but I understand him to be equally clear as to telling people how it was 
manufactured. 
Mr. Seymour : I wish your Lordship would ask him that question. 
Mr. Justice Blackburn : No, I will not. I asked a question which I 
thought was left unasked, in order that there might be no mistake about the 
matter. Go on with the next witness. 
Mr. GLOVER sworn : examined by Mr, Seymodb. 
Q. You are a merchant, I think, at Warwick ? — A. Yes. 
Q. Have you dealt largely, and supplied customers largely, in your own and 
the surrounding counties, with linseed-cake? — A. I have. 
Q. When did you commence dealing with Messrs. Ayre, Brothers? — 
A. About six years back, I should think. 
Q. Did they introduce to you this Triangle Best ? — A, They did, in 1868. 
Q. Where did you see them — at Hull, or did they see you at Warwick V — 
A. At Warwick. 
Q. You saw Mr. Ayre, I believe — did you commence dealing with them for 
the supply of that cake ? — A. We did. 
Q. What is the " Triangle Best Unseed-cake" known as in the trade? — A, 
Asa second quality of cake. 
Q. Have you bought pme linseed-cake ? — A. We have. 
Q. What was said bj' Messrs. Ayre to you about this cake? — A. It was 
offered to us in the place of a second quality that we had been having before, 
which we had had great complaints about. Since that time — since 1868 — I 
think we have sold about 300 tons a year of this same quality, and we have 
uot had a single complaint. 
Q. But besides pure linseed-cake, what other cakes are there that you 
know of as being sold in the market ? — A. We have not sold anything but 
the second quality and the pure. 
Q. Until you ;,'ot this substitute for the second quality ? — A. That is what 
I am speaking of — the " Triangle Best." That is what we are selling now. 
Q. 1 thought yuu said that Messrs. Ayre sup]ilied that to you in place of a 
second quality, of which you complained ? — A. Yes. 
Q. Do you recollect the name of that second quality that you had been 
having.? — A. To my best recollection it was " B." 
Q. Did you know anything from Mr. Ayre whether this was mixed or pure ? 
Mr. Field : Would you kindly — I ask you particularly, Mr. Seymour — oblige 
me by putting your questions in a difierent form ? 
Mr. Justice Blackburn : You really must not lead. You will pardon mc 
for saying so, but I really do think Mr. Fielil is justified. You are rather too 
much telling the witnesses what you think, in place of asking them what they 
Bay. If you ask him what it was that passed between them he wilbtell yon. 
Mr. Seymour : Then you have heard the question — do you recollect what 
did pass between you and Mr. Ayre about this cake ?^ — A. I do not quite. 
It was explained to us what cake this was. There was a " K Pure " cake 
offered, and this Triangle cake at the same time. 
Q. That is what I wanted to know from you, Mr. Glover. — A. I bought it 
understanding quite what the cake was, and when I have sold cake I always 
sold from sample. We have had a " K Pure " cake, and we have had a 
" Triangle " cake. 
Mr. J ustice Blackburn : You are asked what passed — you say it was ex- 
plained. You are asked what it was explained to you to be. — A. WeU, I 
