2G3 
Mr. Pattison.— The character of the change is one that indicates to 
me there was a purpose in it. 
Mr. Bradlaugh. — But does not change of phenomena always presuppose 
a precedent phenomenon, and therefore a discontinuance ? 
Mr. Pattison. — No, I know nothing beyond the phenomena, nor do you. 
The Chairman.— M r. Bradlaugh must admit that we must come not to 
physical causes, but to metaphysical causes, for origination. (Hear, hear.) 
The Meeting then terminated. 
VOL. V. 
x 
