122 
GOLDSTEIN’S NOMINA NUDA OF CATENICELLIDAE 
limit of tlie erection of these names. On the evidence of 
“Catenicella” constricta Goldstein MS., which was described 
by Macgillivray (1884) as “Catenicella” utriculus , the latest 
limit is defined. 
A bound series of “jellygraph” copies of drawings hv Busk 
in the British Museum (Nat. Ilist.), bearing the inscription 
in Busk’s handwriting: “These are all original figures from 
specimens, excepting Calpidium ornatum. Nov., 1881,” con- 
tains figures of specimens of the nomina nuda in question and 
therefore these specimens must have been examined by Busk 
prior to this date. A copy of this MS. work of Busk, obtained 
on loan through Sir Sidney F. Harmer from the British 
Museum, showed that there is nothing in the explanation of 
the figures to indicate that Goldstein’s forms were MS. species 
and, since Miss Jelly is known to have possessed a copy of 
this work, it is presumed that she regarded them as having 
been described, but not knowing where they were described, 
she included them in the catalogue for the sake of complete- 
ness. The placing of two of Macgillivray ’s species described 
in 1887 in the synonymy of Goldstein’s MS. species is also 
thus explained. 
Goldstein apparently confused the application of his MS. 
names, for some of them are applied to different forms. From 
Busk’s “jellygraphs,” drawings made by Sir Sidney F. 
Harmer of slides in the Manchester Museum (Waters and 
Jelly Collections) and the series of slides under consideration, 
the following correlation is made : 
Catenicella constricta = Vittaticella utriculus (Mac- 
gillivray, 1884) in present series (Nat. Mus. Coll., No. 
69247)." 
Catenicella inflata = Vittaticella elegans robusta var. 
nov. in present series (Nat. Mus. Coll., No. 69248). 
Catenicella maccoyi — ? Scuticella margaritacea (Busk, 
1852) in Busk’s “jellygraphs” (p. 7) ; a slide labelled 
thus is described by Bale (1922) as Claviporella gold- 
steini sp. nov. (= Claviporella imperforata Mac- 
gillivray, 1887). 
Catenicella monstrosa — Scuticella subventricosa sp. nov. 
in present series (Nat. Mus. Coll., No. 69249) and in 
the Jelly Collection (Manchester Museum). 
Catenicella perplexa = Scuticella margaritacea (Busk, 
1852) in Busk’s “jellygraphs” (p. 4). 
