PHILEMON PLUMIGENIS. 
Hoary-throated Honey-eater. 
Tropidorhynclms, n. sp., Wall. Ann. & Mag. Nat. Hist. 1857, xx. p. 473. 
Tropidorhynchus plumigenis, Gray, Proc. Zool. Soc. 1858, pp. 174, 191. — Id. Cat. Birds New Guinea, pp. *24, 50 
(1859). — Id. Proc. Zool. Soc. 1861, p. 434. — Finsch, Neu-Guinea, p. 165 (1865). — Rosenb. Reis. n. 
Zuidoostereil, p. 79 (1867).— Meyer, Sitz. k. Akad. Wien, lxx. p. 144 (1874).— Rosenb. Malay Arch, 
p. 365 (1878-79). 
Philemon plumigenis. Gray, Hand-list of Birds, i. p. 160, no. 2081 (1.869). — -Sal v ad. P. Z. S. 1878, p. 88. Id. Ann. 
Mus. Civic. Genov, xiv. p. 655 (1879), xvi. p. 79 (1880).— Id. Report Voy. ‘Challenger,’ ii. p. 70 
(1880).— Id. Orn. Papuasia, etc. ii. p. 353 (1881).— Sclater, Proc. Zool. Soc. 1883, p. 51. 
The Timor Laut examples of this species cannot be said to be strictly identical with the Philemon plumigenis 
of the Ke Islands, for the bead is so much paler brown, more like that of Philemon bouruensis, which it further 
resembles in having* the light mottling above the eye, on the ear-coverts, and sides of face. There can be no 
doubt that P. plumigenis and P. bouruensis are very closely allied — so closely, indeed, that it is not easy to assign 
distinct specific characters to them. 
In our article on Oriolus dccipiens we have drawn attention to the way in which its plumage mimics that of 
the present species of Honey-eater, and we would invite our readers to compare the descriptions and 
figures of the two birds, and to notice how wonderful is the resemblance between them, even to such details 
as the light hind neck, the appearance of an eyebrow, and the blackish colour of the Oriole’s side face, where 
the bare skin occurs in the Honey-eater. Mr. Forbes tells ns that the resemblance is even carried out in 
their mode of life, and that they are difficult to tell when sitting in the same tree, were it not for the 
difference of their notes. 
We have described here an adult male collected by Mr. Forbes in the Teniinber Islands. 
Adult male. General colour above brown, a little paler on the head and mantle ; the lower back, rump, 
and upper tail-coverts darker and more ashy brown ; feathers of the crown somewhat lanceolate in shape, 
with narrow blackish shaft-lines and dusky centres, not sufficiently pronounced to impart a streaked appear- 
ance ; wing-coverts and quills brown, shaded with ashy on the outer webs of the quills ; tail-feathers light 
brown, rather paler at their ends and crossed with dusky bars under certain lights ; sides of the face and 
region of the eye bare, as well as the ear-spot ; ear-coverts and hinder cheeks brown, the fore part of the 
cheeks washed with hoary whitish ; sides of neck hoary grey, extending in a narrow collar round the hind 
neck; throat and fore neck hoary, the malar line brown ; remainder of under surface of body pale ashy 
brown, the chest with narrow dark-brown shaft-stripes ; axillaries and under wing-coverts like the breast, 
washed with rufous on the edge of the wing ; quills dusky brown below ; “ bill, legs, and feet black ; iris 
dark brown ” (//. O. Forbes'). 
[H. 13. S.J 
