October 23, 1884. ] 
JOURNAL OF HORTICULTURE AND COTTAGE GARDENER 
367 
TEAS AND NOISETTES {Continued). 
Position in 
Analysis. 
Name of Rose. 
Date of 
Introduction. 
Raiser’s Name. 
Per-centage of 
Total Number 
of T.’s and N.’s 
tabulated. 
10 
Caroline Kuster (N.) . 
1872 
Pp.rnpif. . 
3 31 
11 
Rubens . 
1859 
Robert. 
3!21 
12 
Comtesse de Nadaillac ... 
1871 
J. B. Guillot, Ills.... 
2.89 
13 
Souvenir de Paul Neyron 
1871 
Levet . 
2.73 
14 
Madame Willermoz . 
1845 
Lacharme . 
2.62 
15 
Anna Ollivier . 
1872 
Ducher . 
2.56 
16 
*Etoile de Lyon. 
1881 
Guillot . 
2.44 
17 
Alba Rosea . 
1862 
Lartey . 
2.15 
18 
Perle des Jardins. 
1874 
Levet . 
2.14 
19 
Madame Lambard . 
1 877 
Lacharme . 
2.13 
20 
Belle Lyonnaise . 
1869 
Levet .. 
2.10 
21 
Madame Bravy. 
1848 
GuiUot, pere. 
1.99 
22 
Madame Margottin. 
1866 
J. B. Guillot, fils.... 
1.52 
23 
Madame Angele Jacquier 
1879 
J. B. Guillot, fils.... 
1.46 
24 
Madame Welche . 
1878 
Ducher . 
1.23 
25 
La Boule d’Or . 
1860 
Margottin . 
1.15 
26 
*Madame Cusin. 
1881 
Guilior, fils. 
1.14 
27 
Gloire de Dijon. 
1853 
JacotoD . 
1.05 
28 
Francisca Kruger. 
1879 
Nabonnand . 
0.98 
29 
Jules Finger. 
1879 
Madame Ducher ... 
0.95 
30 
Amazone. 
1872 
Ducher . 
0.94 
31 
Souvenir de Mad. Pernet 
1875 
Pernet. 
0.94 
32 
Moire . 
1844 
Moire . 
0.84 
33 
Bouquet d’Or. 
1872 
Ducher. 
0.79 
34 
Adam . 
1833 
Adam . 
0.73 
35 
Jean Pernet . 
1867 
Pernet. 
0.73 
36 
Madame Bbrard. 
1870 
Levet . 
0.68 
37 
Homere . 
1859 
Moreau-Robert . 
0.63 
38 
Mad. Hippolyte Jamain ... 
1869 
J. B. Guillot, fils ... 
0.63 
39 
Triomphe de Rennes (N.) 
1857 
Lans(Szeur . 
0.63 
40 
Marie Guillot. 
1874 
J. B. Guillot, fils ... 
0.56 
41 
Comte de Paris. 
1814 
Madame Pean . 
0.52 
42 
Josephine Mai ton. 
A 
43 
Monsieur Furtado. 
1866 
rjT.fFay. 
0 42 
44 
Celine Forestier (N.) . 
1858 
Trouillard . 
0 37 
45 
Madame Camille . 
1871 
Guillot, fils. 
0.37 
46 
Marcelin Rhoda . 
1872 
Ducher. 
0 37 
47 
Perle de Lyon . 
1872 
Diinhp.r. 
0 37 
48 
Comtesse Riza du Parc ... 
1876 
Schwartz. 
o!33 
49 
Reve d’Or (N.) . 
1869 
Ducher. 
0 32 
50 
David Pradel.. 
1851 
0.26 
The Rose occupying the premier place in the above list 
cannot be said to be such a high-class flower as some other 
Tea and Noisette Roses I might name, but for general use¬ 
fulness and dependability it has evidently no equal in its 
class, and now and again it comes so extremely beautiful as 
to out-rival for the time all the Tea-scented varieties shown 
in the same stand with it. Marechal Niel will be seen to 
run Souvenir d’un Ami very close indeed for flrst honours; 
and without doubt, but for the trying winters of 1878-9, 
1879-80, and 1880-81, would have come out far and away 
the best of all the exhibition Teas and Noisettes. Some of 
our oldest Tea Roses continue to hold very prominent posi¬ 
tions—for instance. Souvenir d’Elise Vardon, Madame Bravy, 
Souvenir d’un Ami, Niphetos, and Devoniensis, although 
now respectively thirty, thirty-six, thirty-eight, forty, and 
forty-six years old, are yet still among the very best Roses 
of their class. Of the new varieties the most frequently 
ftaged this year have been Etoile de Lyon, Madame Cusin, 
Madame Angele Jacquier, and Francisca Kruger. I again 
take the opportunity of pointing out that the places given to 
these new Roses are all more or less doubtful. As a rule, 
they come out higher, I think, than they should do. There 
are, fortunately, only two synonymous varieties in this class 
which are in any way affected by their rival claims as exhi¬ 
bition flowers, and these are Alba Rosea and Madame Bravy, 
either of which would stand much higher in the table “ were 
t’other dear charmer away.” 
The following lists will, I trust, be found useful to those 
making a selection of Roses, and wishing to know which are 
the best varieties in the different shades of colour. 
* Its per-centage for 1884 alone regulates the position of this new Rose. 
THE HYBRID PERPETUALS IN THE FOREGOING ANALYSIS 
ARRANGED ACCORDING TO COLOUR. 
Light Roses. 
(Shades of White, Pale Pink, or Light Rose. 
Relative 
Positions 
in 
Analysis. 
Varieties. 
Relative 
Positions 
in 
Analysis. 
Varieties. 
1 
La France 
14 
Monsieur Noman 
2 
Baroness Rothschild 
15 
Edou ird Morren 
3 
Madame Gabriel Luizet 
16 
Marie Cointet 
4 
Captain Christy 
17 
Madame Eugene Verdier 
5 
Marguerite de St. Amand 
18 
Elie Morel 
6 
Merveille de Lyon 
19 
Abel Grand 
7 
Madame H. Jamain 
20 
fSouvenier de la Mai- 
8 
Duchesse de Vallom- 
maison 
brosa 
21 
Princess Beatrice 
9 
Madame Lacharme 
22 
Princess Mary of Cam- 
10 
Pride of Waltham 
bridge 
11 
Comtesse de Serenye 
23 
Marquise de Mortemart 
12 
13 
Marie Finger 
Eugbnie Verdier 
24 
Lady Mary Fitzwilliam 
t Bourbon. 
Medium Roses. 
(Shades of Deep Pink or Bright Rose.) 
Relative 
Positions 
in 
Analysis. 
Varieties. 
Relative 
Positions 
in 
Analysis. 
Varieties. 
1 
Marquise de Castellane 
17 
Alfred Dumesnil 
Frangois Michelon 
18 
Hippolyte Jamain 
o 
O 
Etienne Levet 
19 
Magna Charta 
4 
Comtesse d’Oxford 
20 
Cheshunt Hybrid 
5 
Marie Verdier 
21 
Madame Sophie Fropot 
6 
Camille Bernardiu 
22 
Madame Nachury 
7 
Dupuy Jamain 
23 
Madame Prosper LaugLer 
8 
Star of Waltham 
24 
Paul Neyron 
9 
John Hopper 
25 
Henii Ledechaux 
10 
Countess of Rosebery 
26 
Madame Clemence Juig- 
11 
Ulrich Brunner 
neaux 
12 
Duchesse de Morny 
27 
Emily Laxton 
13 
Annie Laxton 
28 
Louise Peyronny 
14 
Victor Verdier 
29 
Frangois Levet 
15 
Mrs. Baker 
30 
Lady Sheffield 
16 
Auguste Rigotard 
31 
Nardy Freres 
Red Roses. 
(Shades of Carmine, Crimson, or Scarlet.) 
Relative 
Positions 
in 
Analysis. 
Varieties. 
Relative 
Positions 
in 
Analysis. 
Varieties. 
1 
Marie Baumann 
16 
Duke of Teck 
o 
A. K. Williams 
17 
Exposition de Brie 
o 
Alfred Colomb 
18 
Duchess of Bedford 
4 
Duke of Edinburgh 
19 
Maurice Bernardin 
5 
Marie Rady 
20 
John Stuart Mill 
6 
Dr. Andry 
21 
Sir Garnet W olseley 
7 
E. Y. Teas 
22 
Antoine Ducher 
8 
Madame Victor Verdier 
23 
Thomas Mills 
9 
Beauty of Waltham 
24 
Annie Wood 
10 
Senateur Vaisse 
25 
Madame Ducher 
11 
Le Havre 
26 
Duchesse de Caylus 
12 
Mrs. Chas. Wood 
27 
Heinrich Schultheis 
13 
General Jacqueminot 
28 
Devienne Lamy 
14 
Ferdinand de Lesseps 
29 
Due de Rohan 
15 
Prince Arthur 
30 
Madame Charles Crapelet 
Dark Roses. 
(Shades of Purple, Dark Crimson, or Maroon.) 
Relative 
Positions 
in 
Analysis. 
Varieties. 
Relative 
Positions 
in 
Analysis. 
Varieties. 
1 
Charles Lefebvre 
9 
Reynolds Hole 
2 
Louis Van Houtte 
10 
Charles Darwin 
3 
Horace Vernet 
11 
Lord Macaulay 
4 
Fisher Holmes 
12 
Pierre Netting 
5 
Duke of Wellington 
13 
Sultan of Zanzibar 
6 
Xavier Olibo 
14 
Duke of Connaught 
7 
Abel CarriSre 
15 
Jean Liabaud 
8 
Prince Camille de Rohan 
