Some Practical Suggestions. 
t 2 
bilities. Much improvement would result if all examining 
authorities ceased to publish a detailed syllabus, and contented 
themselves with a general statement regarding their requirements. 
In the examination itself, much more stress should he given to 
the practical papers which should he conducted under conditions 
as unconstrained as possible, the candidate being given ample 
time. A properly conducted practical test is the best means of 
ascertaining the candidate’s capabilities. 
A candidate should be given credit for work done during the 
course. The marks allotted should be in proportion to the maximum 
obtainable at the examination, and should he based on a carefully 
thought out scheme in order to avoid the obvious pitfalls. 
5. RESEARCH .—The memorandum states “ Research or 
at least, a practical introduction to the methods of research should 
he an integral part of graduation work in the honours school. . . .” 
It is doubtful if any will disagree with this suggestion provided that 
it does not mean that publication of results is of a necessity to 
follow. Personally 1 feel that Editors are too kind hearted and 
sometimes publish papers in order to encourage young botanists. 
By so doing, the standard is lowered. Most working botanists 
over a certain age must have remarked that some papers contain 
nothing new, and are built up of facts which are familiar to anyone 
with a more or less extended laboratory experience. 
6. CONCLUSION .—When a sufficient number of botanists 
have expressed their opinion on the present question, 1 should like 
to suggest that the Editor convene a small central committee 
of representative and responsible botanists to consider the 
whole question and to agree on a course of action. The result 
should be communicated to the teachers of each University, or 
corresponding institution, who should devise the plan of action 
suitable for the local conditions. It is desirable for the central 
committee to be permanent in order that advice may be given to 
ocal committees, and action co-ordinated. 
I am, Sir, 
Your obedient Servant, 
T. G. HILL. 
