'OR 
Rotzell’s Birds of Narberth, Pa., and Vicinity. 3 —This is a briefly 
annotated list of 10S species. It does not profess to be a complete list of 
the birds of the limited area of which it treats, but is excellent as far 
as it goes, giving briefly just the information most desired in a local list. 
It includes only such species as have been personally noted by the writer, 
•and forms a good point of departure for further additions, which the 
author solicits aid in making. He says that he has “refrained from 
leeoiding any except those that are well authenticated, preferring that 
’future observations should add to the list rather than take from it” — a 
rule compilers of local lists would do well to always follow. The list is 
printed with good taste and presents an attractive appearance.—J. A. A. 
