90 
IlERAMIC STUDIO 
border is not good in invention. Border No. 5 is best in dark and liglit, but 
small form below not heavy enough to hold the design together. No. 6 is 
interesting; too intricate, it would be better if the line were about twice as 
heavy. 
Prob. in. Botli solutions are good e\-ery way. The Hollyhock is espec- 
ially fine. 
E. C. A. — Problem I. Solutions all good — judgment correct as to com- 
parative merit of designs. 
Prob. II. Fig. 7, 11, 13 all good in design and spacing, proportion of dark 
should be slightly increased by widening the hne. No. 11 is best; 13 would 
be improved with a small dark form in triangular space. Plate design not 
good; too much motion, too large and not weU spaced. 
Prob. III. Solutions are aU too spotty and proportion of dark too great. 
L. B. H. — Prob. I. Solutions all cut up into too small areas like a checker 
board, impossible to take in the idea intended at a glance. 
Prob. II. Borders. Figs. 4, 9 and 24 are good in every way. Plate 
border a little heavy for plate ornament, would be better if base was not quite 
so much narrower than top. 
Prob. III. Solutions are not weh understood, they are not compositions 
in any sense. 
D. C. — Prob. I. Solutions 3 and 4 are good in dark and light. In No, 
4 the wliirling motion is unpleasant as it is not|appropriatc for a square, the 
^t/// S.u slm. 
