
          Moderately juicy, sweet, moderately rich, fairly good,
10/1/ 25.  Noted as having a good deal of water core
and too immature for quality to be developed.

1925 notes mentioned unattractiveness of fruit.
while 1927 notes stated it was probably
less unattractive than in 1925.

Apparently most of the lots were picked; or
at least examined too early for best
quality of the variety to have developed.  Where
reference was made to fairly good
quality, fruit was well matured.
See storage notes for further
quality report.

Pom. No. 40632 traces to Pom. No. 11720
which was fruit of Carbough from
C. S. Scott. Sinks Grove, W. Va.

Scions were sent by Mr. Irwin
from his private collection to Arlington
3/19/07 under Pom. No. 38016. Not known
whether propagated or not.
        