165 
with the term ‘ prefrontal,’ nor is it a synonym of < 
are meant not only the ‘ anterior frontals’ of Cuvier in Fishes and Reptiles, but also hi 
‘os en ceinture’ in Batrachians and parts of his ‘ ethmoide’ in Birds aid Mee 
the term ‘ prefrontal’ is the sign of the settlement of a homological question which ee) 
far from being an easy one or of obvious attainment when it became my duty to 
grapple with it in describing the Osteological Series” of the Museum salen 
charge in 1843. Notwithstanding the devotion of twelve 
; : pages’ to that subject, by 
which I believe that now the matter ought to be sufficiently plain, Dr. Melville is 
unable to understand it. Accepting the choice offered by Cuvier in the skull of 
birds, he takes the opposite of that to which Cuvier inclined*, Seeing that of the 
three names which Cuvier had given to what I believe to be one and the same bone, 
two of them were applied to it in pretty equal proportions of the vertebrate series, I 
balanced for a while whether to adopt ‘ ethmoid’ or ‘ anterior frontal.’ I considered, 
however, that by ‘ethmoide’ Cuvier meant not only the neurapophysial part of the 
prefrontal, but also the superior portions of the rhinal or turbinal capsules, and that 
the term, moreover, borrowed from anthropotomy, indicated a structure which, with 
the two exceptions discovered by me in the class of Birds, was limited to Mammals, 
and not constant in that class. Inclining, then, to the name referring to the bone in 
question in Fishes and Reptiles, 1 constructed a term near enough to it to suggest so 
much of the homology as was true, but sufficiently distinct from it to show that it was 
not a synonym, but signified something different and much besides. 
In ordinary birds the olfactory nerves, or rather rhinencephalic crura, emerge from 
the cranium at the upper angle between the hind wall, roof, and septum of the orbit, 
groove the upper part of the septum as they pass forward to penetrate the prefrontal, 
and expand into the rhinencephalon, dispersing the olfactory nerves to the turbinal 
membranes. ‘The frontal olfactory foramen in Raptores is smaller than the prefrontal 
one. Between the Vulture and the Crocodile the difference is that the rhinencephalic 
crura extend along a common canal above the interorbital space in the Reptile, while 
in the Bird the ossification of the septum divides the rhinencephalic fossa into two. 
The bones which hold the neurapophysial relation to the rhinencephalon, anterior to 
the frontals, are the same or homologous in both Ovipara; but in the Bird the 
secondary peripheral or apophysial developments of the prefrontals are suppressed, as 
in Batrachians and some fishes (Xiphias), in which they form the anterior wall of the 
" © On the Archetype and Homologies of the Vertebrate Skeleton,” pp. 46-59. ! 
? The bone which has heretofore been denominated the lachrymal in birds is undoubtedly the homologue of 
the prefrontal in the cranium of fishes and reptiles. The true lachrymal bone, which is external to the lachrymal 
duct, exists in certain Saurians and in the Crocodilide ; it does not occur in the higher Vertebrates (Aver ei 
Mammalia), while the prefrontal only disappears in certain exceptional instances among mammals; in birds 
: .d Hunterian 
and mammals it has erroneously been regarded as the true lachrymal, and is so named iy fe See ” Se, 
Professor; this false homology masks one of the most beautiful instances of the unity of orga , 
(‘Osteology of the Dodo,’ 4to, p- 87, 1848.) 
anterior frontal.’ By * prefrontals ’ 
