sor of Geology 
SALISBURY N 
Geographic Geology TH E U IVE RS bine 0 e e HI CAGO 
P. IDDINGS 
Gseor of Petrology Founded by JOHN D, ROCKEFELLER 
PENROSE, JR. s 
sor of Economic Geology ; ; 
VAN HISE . WILLIAM R. HARPER, President 
sor of Pre-Cambrian Geolony. 
. WALCOTT — = 
sor of Paleontologic Geology 
H. HOLMES s ner sde ty 
ssor of Aeiiele 2 Geology Bates 
‘ 
CHICAGO August 
My dear Professor Holmesi=- 
_l have received your eece separ 
have re-read very carefull¥ vour article in the American 
by discerning people. I em astonished at the weakness of 
those presented by the photographs, there is scarcely a ra 
Very truly yours 
a Professor W. H. Holmes. 
1693. 
rates and 
Geologist. 
‘I do not see how any one can fail to be convinced by the conjoint 
eviderce of these three papers. I think you ha ve made your case 
good, and that it will be So recornized with pra etica "3 une iss ip 
4 7- 
vite he W 
Commersville case as shown by the photographs in the anthropolo;ri- 
cal exhibit. If the conditions at the time of the find were 
tional 
possibility that the flake/stone was found in undisturbed gravels. 
LOBE a 
