a 
ahi” 
———— ee 
14 
dent, vice-president, and secretary, and shall keep a record of all 
returns and reports by the individual judges, as hereinafter pro- 
vided for. 
DUTIES OF JUDGES, 
Rute V. It shall be the duty of each individual judge to 
make a report in writing, over his signature, of the result of the 
examination of each exhibit primarily examined by him, as 
each examination shall have been completed; and as to every 
exhibit so examined which he shall deem worthy of an award, 
he shall formulate in words the specific points of excellence or 
advancement disclosed thereby, and which, in his opinion, ren- 
der it worthy ofan award. Every report shall be submitted as 
soon as possible to the committee of which such judge is a mem- 
ber, for a finding in the premises; and in every case where, by 
the vote of the majority of such-committee, it is determined that 
an exhibit is worthy of receiving an award, said committee shall 
forthwith formulate in written words the specific points of excel- 
lence or advancement which, in its opinion, warrant the award, 
and transmit the same, certified by its president, or vice-president, 
and secretary, to the Executive Committee on Awards. And in 
case the finding. of the committee shall differ from the conclusion 
of the individual judge making the preliminary examination, 
either as to its being worthy of an award or as to the character 
of the points of excellence or advancement it possesses, it shall 
be so distinctly stated in the report of said committee. In every 
case where the finding of the departmental committee coincides 
with the conclusion of the individual judge, the said committee 
shall transmit with such finding the report of such individual 
judge to the Executive Committee on Awards; and in those cases 
where the finding of the departmental committee does not coin- 
cide with the conclusion of the individual judge, then the finding 
in each such case shall be accompanied by the written report of 
one of its members who shall have examined the exhibit, formu- 
lating therein in words the specific points of excellence or 
advancement possessed by such exhibit. 
Rute VI. _ In every case where the finding of the committee 
is not in accord with the conclusion of the individual judge, it 
shall be within the power of the Executive Committee on Awards, 
