488 
JOURNAL  OF  HORTICULTURE  AND  COTTAGE  GARDENER. 
Jane  3,  1847 
Mr.  Prescott,  with  Mr.  Barlow,  Adonis,  and  Wm.  Wilson  ;  fifth,  Mr.  Moor- 
house,  with  A.  M ‘Gregor,  Bridesmaid,  and  Sir  J.  Paxton;  sixth,  Mr.  Kitchen, 
with  Mabel,  Martin’s  117,  and  Sir  J.  Paxton ;  seventh,  Mr.  Mellor,  with 
A.  M’Gregor,  Adonis,  and  Sulphur ;  eighth,  Mr.  Morris,  with  Mrs.  Collier, 
Adonis,  and  Sulphur. 
feathered,  and  Annie  McGregor,  flamed  roses ;  Mrs.  Pickerill,  feathered,  and 
Adonis,  flamed  bybloemens.  Se-ond,  Mr.  John  Morris,  Bedford  Leigh,  with  Sir 
Joseph  Paxton,  feathered  and  flamed  bizarres;  Industry,  feathered,  and  Mdme. 
St  Amaud,  flameu  roses,  Violet  Amiable,  feathered,  and  Lord  Denman,  flamed 
bybloemens.  Third,  Mr.  A.  Collinge,  Middleton,  with  Sir  Joseph  Paxton, 
feathered  and  flamed  bizarres ;  Modesty,  feathered,  and  Aglaia  flamed  roses, 
Alice  Grey,  feathered,  and  Duchess  of  Sutherland,  flamed  bybloemens. 
Class  4.  Three  feathered  Tulips. — First,  Rev.  F.  D.  Horner,  with  Master¬ 
piece,  Modesty,  and  Mrs.  Cooper;  second,  Mr.  Prescott,  with  Lord  Lilford. 
Modesty,  and  Bessie;  third,  Air.  Needham,  with  Wm.  Annibal,  Modesty,  and 
Elizabeth  Pegg;  fourth,  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Masterpiece,  Comte  de  Vergennes, 
and  William  Bentley  ;  fifth,  Mr.  Morris,  with  John  Ratcliffe,  Modesty,  and 
Bessie ;  sixth,  Mr.  Moorhouse,  with  Masterpiece,  Modesty,  and  Trip  to 
Stockport. 
Class  5.  Three  flamed  Tulips. — First,  Rev.  F.  D.  Horner,  with  Samuel 
Barlow,  Mabel,  and  an  unknown  variety ;  second,  Mr.  Needham,  with  Sir 
Joseph  Paxton,  Mabel,  and  Talisman  ;  third,  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Dr.  Hardy, 
Mabel,  and  Mrs.  Ramsbottom ;  fourth,  Mr.  Morris,  with  Sir  Joseph  Paxton, 
Mabel,  and  Lord  Denman  ;  fifth,  Mr.  Prescott,  with  Sir  Joseph  Paxton,  Annie 
M ‘Gregor,  and  Lord  Denman ;  sixth,  Mr.  Haynes,  with  Sir  Joseph  Paxton, 
Mabel,  and  Adonis. 
Class  fi.  Pair  of  Tulips ,  one  feathered  and  one  flamed,  for  maiden  growers. 
— First,  Mr.  G.  Edom,  Epsom,  Surrey,  with  Sir  Joseph  Paxton  and  Mrs.  Lea ; 
second,  Mr.  Collinge,  with  Sir  Joseph  Paxton  and  Alice  Grey. 
Class  7.  Pair  of  Tulips,  one  feathered  and  one  flamed. — First  (Samuel 
Barlow  Memorial  Prize),  Mr.  Prescott,  with  Sir  Joseph  Paxton  and  Annie 
McGregor;  second,  Mr.' Needham,  with  Sir  Joseph  Paxton  and  Masterpiece; 
third,  Rev.  F.  D.  Horner,  with  Sir  Joseph  Paxton  and  Miss  Edwards;  fourth, 
Mr.  Bentley,  with  Sir  Joseph  Paxton  and  Masterpiece ;  fifth,  Mr.  Haynes, 
with  Sir  Joseph  Paxton  and  George  Hayward;  sixth,  Mr.  Moorhouse,  with 
Sir  Joseph  Paxton  and  Masterpiece. 
Class  8.  Single  Blooms. — 
Feathered  Bizarres. 
1  Mr.  Moorhouse,  with  Masterpiece 
^  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Lord  F. 
Cavendish 
3  Mr.  Needham,  with  Storer’s  106 
4  Mr.  Prescott,  with  Lord  Lilford 
5  Mr.  Bentley,  with  General  Grant 
6  Mr.  Haynes,  with  Ajax 
7  Mr.  Morris,  with  Sulphur 
8  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Duke  of  Devon¬ 
shire 
9  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Lord  Stanley 
10  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Sir  Jos.  Paxton 
Feathered  Bybloemens. 
1  Mr.  Kitchen,  with  Trip  to  Stock- 
port 
2  Mr.  Needham,  with  King  of  the 
Universe 
3  Mr.  Needham,  with  Elizabeth 
Begg 
4  Mr.  Kitchen,  with  Violet  Amiable 
5  Mr.  Needham,  with  Queen  of  the 
May 
6  Mr.  Moorhouse,  with  Trip  to  Stock- 
port 
7  Mr.  Needham,  with  Adonis 
8  Mr.  Needham,  with  Bessie 
9  Mr.  Needham,  with  Mrs.  Jackson 
10  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Lord  Melbourne 
Feathered  Roses. 
1  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Mrs.  "Wood 
2  Mr.  Prescott,  with  Industry 
3  Rev.  F.  D.  Horner,  with  Miss 
Edwards 
4  Mr.  Wood,  with  Modesty 
5  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Julia  Farnese 
6  Mr.  Kitchen,  with  Clio 
7  Mr.  Needham,  with  Madame  St 
Arnaud 
8  Mr.  Needham,  with  Mabel 
9  Mr.  Morris,  with  Heroine 
10  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Comte  de 
Vergennes 
t 
Flamed  Bizarres. 
1  Rev.  F.  D.  Horner,  with  Sir  Jos. 
Paxton 
2  Rev.  F.  D.  Horner,  with  Sir  Jos. 
Paxton 
3  Mr.  Kitchen,  with  San  Josef 
4  Rev.  F.  D.  Horner,  with  Ajax 
5  Mr.  Needham,  with  S.  Barlow 
6  Mr.  Needham,  with  Hepworth’s 
Seedling 
7  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Sulphur 
8  Mr.  Haynes,  with  Dr.  Hardy 
9  Mr.  Needham,  with  Dr.  Hutcheon 
10  Mr.  Needham,  with  Sulphur 
Class  12.  Single  Blooms. — 
Bizarre  Breeders. 
1  Rev.  F.  D.  Horner,  with  Sir  J. 
Paxton 
2  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Goldfinder 
3  Rev.  F.  D.  Horner,  with  Wm.  Lea 
4  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Sir  J.  Paxton 
5  Rev.  F.  D.  Horner,  with  Seedling 
6  Rev.  F.  D.  Horner,  with  Seedling 
7  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Richard  Yates 
8  Mr.  Needham,  with  Lloyd’s  Seed¬ 
ling 
Feathered  Bizarres. 
1  Mr.  Needham,  with  Wm.  Annibal 
2  Mr.  Needham,  with  Wm.  Annibal 
3  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Masterpiece 
4  Mr.  Kitchen,  with  Sulphur 
6  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Lord  F.  Caven¬ 
dish 
6  Mr.  Kitchen,  with  Paul  Pry 
7  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Garibaldi 
8  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Luke  Ashmole 
9  Mr.  Needham,  with  Magnum  Bonum 
Rose  Breeders. 
1  Rev.  F.  D.  Horner,  with  Lady 
Grosvenor 
2  Rev.  F.  D.  Horner,  with  Rosy  Morn 
3  Mr.  Moorhouse,  with  Mabel 
4  Rev.  F.  D.  Horner,  with  Mrs. 
Barlow 
5  Mr.  Bentley,  with  A.  M'Gregor 
6  Rev.  F.  D.  Horner,  with  Lady 
Grosvenor 
7  Rev.  F.  D.  Horner,  with  Aurora 
8  Rev.  F.  D.  Horner,  with  Seedling 
No.  8 
Feathered  Roses. 
1  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Modesty 
2  Mr.  Needham,  with  Modesty 
3  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Julia  Farnese 
4  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Mabel 
5  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Alice 
6  Mr.  Kitchen,  with  Heroine 
7  Mr.  Dymock,  with  Seedling 
8  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Mrs.  Wood 
9  Mr.  Needham,  with  Mrs.  Collier 
Byblcemen  Breeders. 
1  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Agnes 
2  Rev.  F.  D.  Horner,  with  Fairy 
3  Rev.  F.  D.  Horner,  with  Fairy  Ring 
4  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Adonis 
5  Rev.  F.  D.  Horner,  with  Seedling 
6  Mr.  Needham,  with  Talisman 
7  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Leach’s  Seedling 
8  Mr.  Needham,  with  Bridesmaid 
The  best  breeder  in  the  show  was  Mr.  Horner’s  seedling  byblosmen  Fairy 
Ring. 
BUTLEY  TULIP  SOCIETY. 
The  seventy-second  annual  exhibition  was  held  at  Butley,  near 
Macclesfield,  on  Friday,  May  28th.  Owing  to  the  unfavourable  nature 
of  the  season  there  were  not  as  many  exhibitors  as  usual,  Messrs.  Wood, 
Prescott,  and  Morris  not  putting  in  an  appearance.  The  quality  of  the 
flowers  left  little  to  be  desired,  and  it  was  eene rally  conceded  that  it 
was  the  best  show  for  many  years.  The  great  prize  at  Butley  is  a  silver 
cup  for  the  best  stand  of  six  rectified  flowers,  one  feathered  and  one 
flamed  of  each  class.  It  was  worthily  won  by  Mr.  J.  W.  Bentley  of 
Stakehill,  with  an  excellent  stand,  comprising  Sir  Joseph  Paxton,  flamed, 
and  John  Mills,  feathered  bizarres  ;  Chancellor,  Aimed,  and  King  of  the 
Universe,  feathered  bybloemens;  Mabel  flamed,  and  Julia  Farnese, 
feathered  roses.  Mr.  C.  W.  Needham  was  a  good  second,  and  Mr.  Kitchen 
third.  The  Judges,  Messrs  H.  Housley  (Stockport)  and  R.  Chadwick 
(Butley).  also  made  the  following  awards. 
Flamed  Roses. 
1  Mr.  Kitchen,  with  Mabel 
2  Mr.  Prescott,  with  Annie  McGregor 
3  Rev.  F.  D.  Horner,  with  Mabel 
4  Mr.  Needham,  with  Queen  of 
England 
5  Mr.  Kitchen,  with  Clio 
6  Rev.  F.  D.  Horner,  with  Industry 
7  Mr.  Needham,  with  Kate  Connor 
8  Dir.  Kitchen,  with  Rose  Hill 
9  Mr.  Wood,  with  Aglaia 
10  Mr.  Kitchen,  with  Rose  Celestial 
Flamed  Bybloemens. 
1  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Mrs.  Rams¬ 
bottom 
2  Mr.  Needham,  with  Hepworth’s 
Seedling 
3  Mr.  Needham,  with  Adonis 
4  Mr.  Haynes,  with  King  of  the 
Universe 
5  Mr.  Haynes,  with  Duchess  of 
Sutherland 
6  Mr.  Morris,  with  Chancellor 
7  Mr.  Morris,  with  Lord.  Denman 
8  Mr.  Dymock,  with  Seedling 
9  Mr.  Horner,  with  Talisman 
10  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Black  Diamond 
Class  9.  The  best  feathered  Tulip  in  the  whole  exhibition. — Mr.  Needham, 
with  William  Annibal.  The  best  flamed  Tulip  in  the  whole  exhibition. — Rev. 
F.  D.  Horner,  with  Sir  Joseph  Paxton. 
Class  10.  Six  dissimilar  breeder  Tulips,  two  of  each  class. — First,  Rev.  F.  D. 
Horner,  with  Mrs.  Barlow  and  Rosy  Morn,  roses ;  Dulcie  and  Fairy  Ring,  byblce- 
mens;  Red  Rover  and  Sir  Joseph  Paxton,  bizarres.  Second,  Mr.  Bentley,  with 
Mrs.  Barlow  and  Rose  Hill,  roses;  Beauty  of  Litchurch  and  Bridesmaid,  byblce- 
mens;  Goldfinder  and  Sir  Jos.  Paxton,  bizarres.  Third,  Mr.  Needham,  with 
Mrs.  Barlow  and  Rose  Hill,  roses ;  Bridesmaid  and  Adonis,  byblcemens ;  Gold¬ 
finder  and  Sir  Jos.  Paxton,  bizarres.  Fourth,  Mr.  Moorhouse,  with  Mrs.  Barlow 
and  Mabel,  roses;  Bridesmaid  and  Agnes,  bybloemens;  Sir  Jos.  Paxton  and 
Dr.  Dalton,  bizarres.  Fifth,  Mr.  Kitchen,  with  Rose  Hill  and  Mrs.  Barlow, 
roses;  Alice  Grey  and  Martin’s  117,  bybloemens;  Sir  Joseph  Paxton  and 
Goldfinder,  bizarres.  Sixth,  Mr.  W.  Mellor,  Wakefield,  with  Mabel  and  A. 
M‘Gregor,  roses ;  George  Hardwick  and  Sarah,  bybloemens;  W.  Wilson  and 
Hardwick’s  Seedling,  bizarres. 
Class  11.  Three  breeder  Tulips,  one  of  each  class. — First,  Rev.  F.  D. 
Horner,  with  Mrs.  Barlow,  Fairy  Ring,  and  Sir  J.  Paxton ;  second,  Mr. 
Bentley,  with  Rose  Hill,  Queen  of  the  May,  and  Lloyd’s  47  ;  third,  Mr. 
Needham,  with  A.  M‘Gregor,  Glory  of  Stakehill,  and  Goldfinder;  fourth, 
Feathered  Bybloemens. 
1  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Besde 
2  Mr.  Needham,  with  King  of  the 
Universe 
3  Mr.  Needham,  with  Elizabeth  Pegg 
4  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Camp’s  Seedling 
5  Mr.  Kitchen,  with  Trip  to  Stockport 
6  Mr.  Needham,  with  Queen  of  the 
May 
7  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Bessie 
8  Mr.  Needham,  with  Wm.  Parkinson 
9  Mr.  Jones,  with  Bertha 
Flamed  Bizarres. 
1  Mr.  Needham,  with  Sir  J.  Paxton 
2  Mr.  Kitchen,  with  San  Josef 
3  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Samuel  Barlow 
4  Mr.  Needham,  with  Dr.  Hardy 
5  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Sulphur 
6  Mr.  Needham,  with  Hepworth’s 
Seedling 
7  Mr.  Needham,  with  Sir  J.  Paxton 
8  Mr.  Needham,  with  J.  Booth 
9  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Lord  Stanley 
Flamed  Roses. 
1  Mr.  Kitchen,  with  A.  M‘Gregor 
2  Mr.  Needham,  with  Aglaia 
3  Mr.  Bentley  with  A.  M‘Gregor 
4  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Madame  St. 
Arnaud 
6  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Mabel 
6  Mr.  Needham,  withTriompheRoyale 
7  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Sarah  Headly 
8  Mr.  Needham,  with  Kate  Connor 
9  Mr.  Kitchen,  with  Rose  Hill 
Flamed  Byblcemens 
1  Mr.  Needham,  with  Talisman 
2  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Mrs.  Ramsbottom 
3  Mr.  Needham,  with  Hepworth’s 
Seedling 
4  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Talisman 
5  Mr.  Kitchen,  with  Duchess  o 
Sutherland 
6  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Black  Diamond 
7  Mr.  Dymock,  with  Seedling. 
8  Mr.  Kitchen,  with  Lord  Denman 
9  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Chancellor 
Three  breeders,  one  of  each  class. — First,  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Lloyd’s  47,  Rose 
Hill,  and  Alice  Grey;  second,  Mr.  Kitchen,  with  Sir  J.  Paxton,  Rose  Hill,  and 
Alice  Grey;  third,  Mr.  Hague,  with  Dr.  Hardy,  Industry,  and  Alice  Grey. 
Bizarre  Breeders. 
1  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Lloyd’s  47  1 
2  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Goldfinder  2 
3  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Sir  J.  Paxton  3 
4  Mr.  Bentley,  with  Excelsior  4 
5  Mr.  Needham,  with  S.  Barlow  5 
Rose  Breeders. 
Mr.  Bentley,  with  A.  M‘Gregor 
Mr.  Needham,  with  Mrs.  Barlow 
Mr.  Bentley,  with  Queen  of  England 
Mr.  Kitchen,  with  Rose  Hill 
Mr.  Needham,  with  Lloyd’s  220 
