Fe\\ Nature VO) Conservation Nature Conservation 56: 77-82 (2024) DOI: 10.3897/natureconservation.56.133441 Letter To The Editor Eight years after the Fundao tailings dam collapse: chaos on the muddy banks Cassio Cardoso Pereira'’”©, Stephannie Fernandes*®, Geraldo Wilson Fernandes'24®, Fernando Figueiredo Goulart*® ee wo NY — Horizonte, MG, Brazil Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, 31270-901, Belo Horizonte, MG, Brazil Knowledge Center for Biodiversity, 31270-901, Belo Horizonte, MG, Brazil Department of Global & Sociocultural Studies and Kimberly Green Latin American and Caribbean Center, Florida International University, 33199, Miami, FL, USA Laboratorio de Ecologia Evolutiva & Biodiversidade, Departamento de Genética, Ecologia e Evolugao, Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, 31270-901, Belo Corresponding author: Cassio Cardoso Pereira (cassiocardosopereira@gmail.com) OPEN Qaceess Academic editor: Klaus Henle Received: 9 May 2024 Accepted: 3 August 2024 Published: 20 August 2024 ZooBank: https://zoobank. org/674AF3BE-F4A3-49C3-A9A2- 10F5F4493F5C Citation: Pereira CC, Fernandes S, Fernandes GW, Goulart FF (2024) Eight years after the Fundao tailings dam collapse: chaos on the muddy banks. Nature Conservation 56: 77-82. https://doi.org/10.3897/ natureconservation.96.133441 Copyright: © Cassio Cardoso Pereira et al. This is an open access article distributed under terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (Attribution 4.0 International - CC BY 4.0). Key words: Biodiversity, Brumadinho, Fundao tailings dam, Mariana dam disaster Eight years have passed since Brazil's worst environmental disaster, the collapse of the Samarco company’s Fundao tailings dam in Mariana, Minas Gerais, Brazil. The mud spill buried the village of Bento Rodrigues and affected, with mud full of heavy metals and metalloids, more than 600 km of the river channel, and marginal habitats. It extended for hundreds of kilometers along the coast, disturbing the sea, coral reefs, mangroves, and beaches (Fernandes et al. 2016; Costa et al. 2022). At the time of the disaster, more than one million people across 35 cities were affected due to the spill of around 50 million m° of mud waste, resulting in 19 deaths, diseases, and hundreds of people displaced (Fernandes et al. 2016; Omachi et al. 2018). The dam breach unleashed a cascade of health and social woes for people living in the area. High levels of heavy metals were found in the blood and urine of riverside populations (Paulelli et al. 2022). There was an increase in diseas- es arising from habitat degradation, when people are exposed to mosquitoes, such as dengue'’s transmitters, as well as enteric pathogens in the water along the Doce River (Nishijima and Rocha 2020). Finally, the livelihoods, health, and culture of indigenous peoples, such as the Krenak, Tupiniquim, Guaranis, and Quilombola populations (afro-descendant communities, predominantly com- posed of the rural and urban black population) were profoundly affected by the disaster (Oliveira et al. 2020; Zhouri and Pascoal 2022). The ecological devastation mirrored the human tragedy (Fig. 1). Approx- imately 346 endangered species on the mainland were negatively impacted by the disaster (Knopff et al. 2020), and increased the risk of extinction of 13 aquatic species, becoming a major threat to three of them (Drummond et al. 2021). Furthermore, there were unexpected impacts such as the bioaccumu- lation of pesticides in endangered Franciscana dolphin [Pontoporia blainvillei (Gervais & d’Orbigny, 1844)], as the mud tsunami stirred up historic deposits of these pollutants from soil and river sediments (Nascimento et al. 2022). 7/ Cassio Cardoso Pereira et al.: Chaos on the muddy banks - 8 " . i i a9 ‘ == - af a . : 4 >" > 1 — | « 4 an, b : ' . i as ~~ oa. ez, SPIE ae tS, ~ te a ae —s ih i “r “ = : . a . a =A ek Figure 1. Dead fish in Marliéria, Minas Gerais, Brazil, about 200 km downstream from the Fundao tailings dam. Photo credit: Elvira Nascimento. To make it worse, heavy summer rains re-suspend contaminants in the conti- nent, while winter cold fronts suspend pollutants from the bottom of the sea every year (Fernandes et al. 2022). Another major concern is invasive alien species. Studies have shown that changes in the substrate and water quality altered the composition of the as- semblage of fish, copepods, and rotifers, favoring non-native species from these groups (Programa de Monitoramento da Biodiversidade Aquatica 2021). Furthermore, another indirect impact of contamination on lake communities was the invasion of water hyacinth (Eichhornia sp.), which increased in lakes and ponds, with a high correlation with increases in the concentration of vana- dium, iron, and zinc found in the water (Programa de Monitoramento da Biodi- versidade Aquatica 2021). Finally, it is worth highlighting the challenge of restoring ecosystems. Remov- ing all the waste that has spread throughout the basin is practically impossible, but the longer the recovery actions take, the greater the risk that the river will be contaminated again by the mud that is still on the banks, especially during periods of rain. To prevent this from happening, the recovery of the riparian forest must be prioritized. For now, emergency actions are being undertaken to try to prevent the mud from flowing into the river, with the planting of grasses and legume trees that would have the function of keeping the land on the bank firmer. However, many of these species are exotic (personal observation) and this brings future environmental problems, unbalancing the entire ecosystem. Even the use of native species can be problematic because by introducing a Nature Conservation 56: 77-82 (2024), DOI: 10.3897/natureconservation.56.133441 78 Cassio Cardoso Pereira et al.: Chaos on the muddy banks limited number of species into a given region, we can inadvertently reduce the ecological functionality of the environment, making it more homogeneous and less diverse (Pereira et al. 2024; Toma et al. 2024). Therefore, the restoration of vegetation in the Rio Doce basin needs to be carried out with a diverse range of native species so that environmental connectivity and restoration of the im- portant ecosystem services on which we depend are more quickly promoted (Pereira et al., 2024; Ramos et al., 2024; Toma et al. 2024). Specific efforts to compensate for socio-environmental impacts have been made by Renova since 2016, a foundation created to repair and compensate for the impacts of Fundao. The foundation has been building housing, compensat- ing residents, and trying to help the affected human populations. However, the process has been very slow and controversial (Losekann and Milanez 2023). Conveniently, the company creates its foundation to repair its own damages. The government should be imposing several measures to solve the problems, demanding reports, assessments and results on what should be done. In other words, it is not right that the company chooses its own professionals to assess these damages. This oversight should be impartial and carried out by the gov- ernment. Local representatives, research institutions, and NGOs should also have a say in what Renova is doing. It is of utmost importance to develop and implement a comprehensive program to provide the necessary assistance to affected families, in addition to implementing a comprehensive restoration and recovery program that would accelerate efforts and go beyond punctual efforts. All mitigation measures may be wasted if the causes of such catastrophes are not addressed. The Mariana accident was repeated in Brumadinho, claiming 272 lives (Vidal et al. 2024). This brought to the fore the discussion about the need to find alternatives for mining activities in the country, which has 839 tail- ings dams (Agéncia Nacional de Mineracao 2024). A law was created in Minas Gerais (Law No. 23,291, of 25/02/2019, Sistema Integrado de Informacao Am- biental 2019) that prevents the construction, installation, expansion, or raising of dams where there is a community in the so-called self-rescue zone: the por- tion of the valley downstream of the dam where there is no time to intervene in an emergency situation. However, these laws do not appear to be obeyed and dams may still be built if there is no alternative method. The best way to replace the problematic tailings dams is dry mining (Davies and Rice 2001). Dry ore beneficiation is ideal because it allows the ore to be processed with very little or no water. In other words, the leftovers from the ore beneficiation are filtered and placed in large piles, replacing the use of tradition- al dams. Dry mining also makes it possible to generate a substrate that can be used in the production of new products, including sand for asphalt paving and bricks for civil construction. In addition, this substrate can be vegetated and, in this way, contribute to the recovery of nature (Davies and Rice 2001). However, this method of beneficiating the ore is much more expensive and, unfortunate- ly, there are still several active tailings dams in Brazil, many of them upstream and in critical condition. It is important to emphasize that it is not enough to simply deactivate these dams, as the mud remains stored and the dam could break at any time. Heavy rains can generate floods that could rupture the res- ervoir. Unfortunately, a common practice among mining companies is to hire technicians to assess the condition of their dams and the risk of rupture. This is as incoherent as “putting a fox to guard a henhouse’”. It is up to the government Nature Conservation 56: 77-82 (2024), DOI: 10.3897/natureconservation.56.133441 79 Cassio Cardoso Pereira et al.: Chaos on the muddy banks to inspect all of this and do an impartial and thorough assessment. Therefore, in addition to replacing the dams with a more modern and safer tailings pro- cessing system, it is essential that these dams be monitored and emptied to prevent overflows. The mud spill is still affecting lives, health, economy, culture, and biodiver- sity. Over the years, the impact has increased in intensity, severity, and area, ranking as one of the major environmental disasters worldwide. In association with other threats such as climate change that induce extreme events such as cyclones and heavy rains, which foster pollutant resuspension, Fundao spills are even more worrisome to terrestrial and aquatic species in a wide range of globally important sites for conservation, as well as for human population that depend on these ecosystems. The path to healing the Rio Doce requires a multi-pronged approach. Effec- tive public policies are essential, encompassing compensation for affected communities, restoration initiatives, and long-term conservation programs. These policies, rooted in current scientific research, should prioritize rebuilding resilient ecosystems and river protections. Collaboration is paramount. Local and indigenous communities hold invaluable knowledge of the Rio Doce and fostering their inclusion provides a sense of ownership over its revival. Partner- ing with scientific experts ensures evidence-based restoration strategies and tracks their effectiveness. By implementing these solutions and supporting a collaborative conservation strategy, the long journey to heal the Rio Doce eco- system and the lives it sustains can truly begin. Acknowledgements The authors thank UFMG, CNPgq, Fapemig, and CAPES for their continuous support. Additional information Conflict of interest The authors have declared that no competing interests exist. Ethical statement No ethical statement was reported. Funding Cassio Cardoso Pereira thanks scholarship from CNPq (173800/2023-8). Geraldo Wil- son Fernandes thanks CNPq, Knowledge Center for Biodiversity (CNPq; 406757/2022- 4), MCTI and FAPEMIG for grant support. Fernando Figueiredo Goulart thanks FINEP for the DTI (Development, Technology and Innovation) scholarship and the Camara Técnica de Biodiversidade CTBio/FLACSO/Renova (N° 002/2022). Author contributions Cassio Cardoso Pereira, Geraldo Wilson Fernandes, and Fernando Figueiredo Goulart con- ceived the ideas; Cassio Cardoso Pereira and Fernando Figueiredo Goulart led the writing of the manuscript. Stephannie Fernandes made edits and also contributed to the main text. All authors contributed critically to the drafts and gave final approval for publication. Nature Conservation 56: 77-82 (2024), DOI: 10.3897/natureconservation.56.133441 80 Cassio Cardoso Pereira et al.: Chaos on the muddy banks Author ORCIDs Cassio Cardoso Pereira © https://orcid.org/0000-0002-601 7-4083 Stephannie Fernandes © https://orcid.org/0000-0002-2049-1164 Geraldo Wilson Fernandes ® https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1 559-6049 Fernando Figueiredo Goulart © https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6327-5285 Data availability All of the data that support the findings of this study are available in the main text. References Agéncia Nacional de Mineracado (2024) Barragens do Brasil. https://app.anm.gov.br/ SIGBM/Publico/GerenciarPublico Costa PG, Marube LC, Artifon V, Escarrone AL, Hernandes JC, Zebral YD, Bianchini A (2022) Temporal and spatial variations in metals and arsenic contamination in wa- ter, sediment and biota of freshwater, marine and coastal environments after the Fundao dam failure. The Science of the Total Environment 806: 151340. https://doi. org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2021.151340 Davies MP, Rice S (2001) An alternative to conventional tailing management — “dry stack” filtered tailings. In: Balkema AA (Ed.) Tailings and Mine Waste ‘01. CRC Press, London, 411-420. Drummond GM, Subira RJ, Martins CS (2021) Livro vermelho da biota aquatica do Rio Doce ameacada de extin¢ao pos-rompimento da barragem de Fundao, Mariana. https://biodiversitas.org.br/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/Livro_Vermelho_Biodiver- sitas_Renova_Rio-Doce.pdf Fernandes GW, Goulart FF, Ranieri BD, Coelho MS, Dales K, Boesche N, Bustamante M, Carvalho FA, Carvalho DC, Dirzo R, Fernandes S, Galetti Jr PM, Millan VEG, Miel- ke C, Ramirez JL, Neves A, Rogass C, Ribeiro SP Scariot A, Soares-Filho B (2016) Deep into the mud: Ecological and socio-economic impacts of the dam breach in Mariana, Brazil. Natureza & Conservacao 14(2): 35-45. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. ncon.2016.10.003 Fernandes L, Jesus H, Almeida P, Sandrini J, Bianchini A, Santos H (2022) The influence of the Doce River mouth on the microbiome of nearby coastal areas three years after the Fundao Dam failure, Brazil. The Science of the Total Environment 807: 151777. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2021.151777 Knopff K, Bede LC, Arruda L, Alves T, Simons B (2020) Methods for Postdisaster Impact Assessment: A Case Study of the Impacts of the Fundao Dam Failure on Terrestrial Species Threatened with Extinction. Integrated Environmental Assessment and Man- agement 16(5): 676-680. https://doi.org/10.1002/ieam.4265 Losekann C, Milanez B (2023) Mining disaster in the Doce River: Dilemma between governance and participation. Current Sociology 71(7): 1255-1273. https://doi. org/10.1177/00113921211059224 Nascimento RL, Alves PR, Di Domenico M, Braga AA, De Paiva PC, D’Azeredo Orlando MT, Sant’Ana Cavichini A, Longhini CM, Martins CC, Neto RR, Grilo CF, Oliveira KSS, Da Silva Quaresma V, Costa ES, Cagnin RC, Da Silva CA, Sa F, De Lourdes Longo L (2022) The Fundao dam failure: Iron ore tailing impact on marine benthic macro- fauna. The Science of the Total Environment 838: 156205. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. scitotenv.2022.156205 Nature Conservation 56: 77-82 (2024), DOI: 10.3897/natureconservation.56.133441 8] Cassio Cardoso Pereira et al.: Chaos on the muddy banks Nishijima M, Rocha FF (2020) An economic investigation of the dengue incidence as a result of a tailings dam accident in Brazil. Journal of Environmental Management 253: 109748. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2019.109748 Oliveira PDC, Di Beneditto APM, Quaresma VDS, Bastos AC, Zappes CA (2020) Tradition- al knowledge of fishers versus an environmental disaster from mining waste in Cen- tral Brazil. Marine Policy 120: 104129. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpol.2020.104129 Omachi CY, Siani SMO, Chagas FM, Mascagni ML, Cordeiro M, Garcia GD, Thompson CC, Siegle E, Thompson FL (2018) Atlantic Forest loss caused by the world's largest tailing dam collapse (Fundao Dam, Mariana, Brazil). Remote Sensing Applications: Society and Environment 12: 30-34. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rsase.2018.08.003 Paulelli ACC, Cesila CA, Devoz PP, Ruella De Oliveira S, Bianchi Ximenez JP, Pedreira Fil- ho WDR, Barbosa Jr F (2022) Fundao tailings dam failure in Brazil: Evidence of a pop- ulation exposed to high levels of Al, As, Hg, and Ni after a human biomonitoring study. Environmental Research 205: 112524. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envres.2021.112524 Pereira CC, Kenedy-Siqueira W, Negreiros D, Fernandes S, Barbosa M, Goulart FF, Athayde S, Wolf C, Harrison IJ, Betts MG, Powers JS, Dirzo R, Ripple WJ, Fearnside PM, Fer- nandes GW (2024) Scientists’ warning: six key points where biodiversity can improve climate change mitigation. Bioscience 74(5): 315-318. https://doi.org/10.1093/ biosci/biae035 Programa de Monitoramento da Biodiversidade Aquatica (2021) Programa de Monito- ramento da Biodiversidade Aquatica da area ambiental | — por¢ao capixaba do rio Doce e regido marinha e costeira adjacente (PMBA/RRDM-FEST). https://www.drop- box.com/sh/1yyjy34mhpexqlw/AAAv1CSgINXkJit8vuDLOKtWa/RA2021_RT_39_fe- v2022?e=1 &lst=&dl=0 Ramos L, Negreiros D, Goulart FF, Figueiredo JCG, Kenedy-Siqueira W, Toma TSP, Justino WDS, Maia RA, De Oliveira JT, Oki Y, Barbosa M, Aguilar R, Dos Santos RM, Dias HM, Nunes YRF, Fernandes GW (2024) Dissimilar forests along the Rio Doce watershed call for multiple restoration references to avoid biotic homogenization. The Science of the Total Environment 930: 172720. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2024.172720 Sistema Integrado de Informagao Ambiental (2019) Lei n° 23.291, de 25 de fevereiro de 2019. https://www.siam.mg.gov.br/sla/download.pdf?idNorma=481 38 Toma TSP, Oliveira HFM, Overbeck GE, Grelle CEV, Roque FO, Negreiros D, Rodrigues DJ, Guimaraes AF, Streit H, Dechoum MS, Fonséca NC, Rocha TC, Pereira CC, Garda AA, Bergallo HG, Domingos FMCB, Fernandes GW (2024) Aim for heterogeneous bio- diversity restoration. Science 383(6681): 376-376. https://doi.org/10.1126/science. adn3767 Vidal EP, Silva RCC, Zucchi P (2024) Impacts of mining disasters on the ambulatory care of the Brazilian national health system: The cases of Mariana and Brumadinho/ Brazil. BMC Health Services Research 24(1): 285. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12913- 023-10385-y Zhouri A, Pascoal WV (2022) From the muddy banks of the Watu: The Krenak and the Rio Doce mining disaster in Brazil. Current Directions in Water Scarcity Research. Elsevier, 145-165. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-824538-5.00008-X Nature Conservation 56: 77-82 (2024), DOI: 10.3897/natureconservation.56.133441 -y)